sign_in_with_apple: Set aud claim so identityToken works with Firebase Auth on Android about dart_packages HOT 11 CLOSED

My apologies @HenriBeck , I was misunderstanding what you were saying, you were absolutely right it was a problem with my configuration, I imagine the screenshot you were going to add was something like this one:

Sorry for taking up your time.

from dart_packages.

@tp OK great, will do - I really appreciate the help getting it working so happy to contribute something. Thanks!

from dart_packages.

@nickmeinhold Have you tried changing your service id to be com.example.project? I can't remember if that was possible to have the same service id + app bundle ID

from dart_packages.

Also, you can just change the service ID in Firebase auth to match the one you have in your Flutter code

from dart_packages.

Thanks for the response @HenriBeck

I can't change the service id to be com.example.project as that is already used as the identifier for my App Id and errors when I try to change it.

When you say "change the service ID in Firebase auth" do you mean the firebase project Id? I could create a new project and move everything over I guess... is that what you're suggesting?

from dart_packages.

@HenriBeck did you mean to close this? I don't think it's been resolved.

from dart_packages.

@nickmeinhold I will post a screenshot of what I mean later. And yeah I meant to close this as it's probably a misconfiguration in your Firebase project itself.

When you setup Sign in with Apple, you also give firebase the clientId and I think you gave the wrong one when you did the initial setup.

from dart_packages.

I spent a lot of time trying to be sure it wasn't my mistake in setting things up, and maybe it was but it feels very dismissive to not have a chance to respond before the issue is closed.

I followed your documentation for the clientId, it seems quite clear to me.

The developer’s client identifier, as provided by WWDR.

This is the Identifier value shown on the detail view of the service after opening it from https://developer.apple.com/account/resources/identifiers/list/serviceId Usually a reverse domain notation like com.example.app.service

As I said, I can't change the Service Id identifier to what Firebase Auth is expecting (which is the firebase project id) because my App Id identifier already uses the same value.

If the plugin will aways produce an id token with an aud claim with the value passed in to clientId and that can't be changed then I think it would be good to add something to the docs to that effect, maybe as a note for people trying to use the plugin with firebase auth, or just somewhere so people like me know to stop trying to figure it out.

I'd have been happy to put up some doc PRs or try and help in some way, I'm not meaning to use this as a helpdesk, but rather trying to help improve the excellent open source software you've made.

from dart_packages.

@nickmeinhold yeah, thats the exact screenshot I wanted to send.

from dart_packages.

I'd have been happy to put up some doc PRs or try and help in some way, I'm not meaning to use this as a helpdesk, but rather trying to help improve the excellent open source software you've made.

@nickmeinhold Thanks for pulling through. As Firebase integration is a common question here, a PR documenting the steps (and potential pitfalls) would be much appreciated 🙇🏻‍♂️

from dart_packages.

Hi @tp , just wanted to check in and let you know I've been working on an example app with some documentation, hopefully to put up as a PR. I started from scratch, created a firebase project and flutter app and got the auth working on both ios and android, taking screenshots at each step and made some docs. The repo is: https://github.com/nickmeinhold/apple-sign-in-flutter-firebase

I think all the necessary steps are in there. I want to improve it a bit before putting a PR up but thought I would check in and see if this is helpful or if you'd prefer a different format or anything.

Thanks!

from dart_packages.