refactoring_sandbox : Proxy shape local Prim changes remain even after delete/recreate or new scene about maya-usd HOT 5 CLOSED

I can confirm this issue also happens in the latest state of the dev branch however the issue does not happen when using the AL_USDMayaPlugin through the USD > Proxy > Import menu. I believe this is due to the Stage cache Id being applied as -1, likely meaning it's forced to a new unique identifier.

However I can't seem to find that similar functionality for the mayaUsdProxyShape or how to exactly reproduce the behavior through code to create the nodes.

from maya-usd.

Just checking back in. Is there currently any way to force/set the Stage cache Id for the mayaUsdProxyShape, e.g. passing it -1 as described above to avoid this "shared state" even across scenes or throughout the whole maya session.

Also, with it currently being able to break like this, could this behavior turn out dangerous? For example, if you have a scene that has stage id 1 and 2. Then you open another file that was saved with two USD proxies with stage ids 2 and 3. What happens with the changes of stage id 2? Does it preserve them and try to apply them in the other scene?

from maya-usd.

Indeed we have two different stage caches at this point. AL plugin is wrapping around UsdUtilsStageCache (https://github.com/PixarAnimationStudios/USD/blob/master/pxr/usd/lib/usdUtils/stageCache.h) and the base proxy has its own stage cache. Something to unify.

I do not have an answer to your question, maybe @mattyjams can chime in?

from maya-usd.

At the USD level, if you have layers being held open by stage caches across Maya scene changes (File->Open, File->New, etc.), then that would probably explain it. You could check this in Maya by making some edits, then doing a File->New and checking whether there are still layers loaded in the layer registry:

Sdf.Layer.GetLoadedLayers()

If that returns any layers after switching to a new scene, then there is probably a stage cache not getting reset and holding those layers open. Re-opening one of those layers is going to return you the version in the stage cache.

We should hopefully be accounting for this in the pxr nodes and the mayaUsdProxyShape with a listener:

from maya-usd.

The issue has been fixed for a while - closing this ticket. @BigRoy please reopen if we missed something.

from maya-usd.