Consistently use `async`/`await` rather than `then`. about aws-toolkit-vscode HOT 5 CLOSED

Not necessarily disagreeing but I'm not clear why 'then' (or any task/promise continuation syntax) is considered 'legacy' or not as clear?

Is there a typescript style guide documented somewhere we should follow and discuss to come up with the right set of tslint settings?

from aws-toolkit-vscode.

async/await is preferred because it allows you to write flat code, rather than adding a level of nesting for each asynchronous call. This makes asynchronous code much easier to read, write, and reason about. The awkward nesting of Tasks/Promises/etc. is the motivation for the async/await feature in the first place.

I don't see await vs then specifically called out in any popular style guide, but any async/await guide will explain the advantages. Some examples:

• TypeScript
• JavaScript
• C#

I don't think that a tslint rule is appropriate, because there are still cases where you might want then:

const promises = []
for (const i = 0; i < 10; i++) {
    promises.append(makePromise(i).then(...))
}

await Promise.all(promises)

You could avoid then by extracting makePromise(i).then(...) into a helper function, but using then here is simpler.

This issue is more about cases like this:

foo(): Promise<string> {
    return somePromise.then(result => {
        return `Hello, ${result}!`
    })
}

Compare to:

async foo(): Promise<string> {
    const result = await somePromise
    return `Hello, ${result}!`
}

from aws-toolkit-vscode.

I have a preference towards async/await as it seems to cut down on explicit Promise usage. In one case, I had wrapped a function in a Promise constructor, which accidentally ate thrown Errors. I chalk that up to gaining familiarity with the language though too.

VS Code Extension development supports promises broadly - https://code.visualstudio.com/docs/extensionAPI/patterns-and-principles#_promises

from aws-toolkit-vscode.

As I said, I don't necessarily disagree. I checked with our Javascript SDK team regarding your use of the term 'legacy' for 'then' usage and they don't consider it such and in fact raised the same discussion that async/await is preferred but sometimes 'then' is useful. Therefore I don't think a broad 'must not use then()' mandate is appropriate.

Our style guide, when we have one, should therefore likely state 'prefer async/await over then()' and show the examples you list as the reason why. Perhaps this issue should mutate into one that creates said style guide in the repo.

from aws-toolkit-vscode.

@steveataws Thanks, that sounds good. I worded this issue poorly--I agree that "prefer" is the right terminology.

from aws-toolkit-vscode.