Ethics of this project about 2015ori-1 HOT 1 CLOSED

Not sure about this, but one things that came to my mind was the following: As I think Project 1 is rather confirmatory, we could already set up the analysis file for the spreadsheet data in advance.

Yes definitely. I need to plan to do this before we get started. That also allows us to preregister.

Suggestion: Jan does the transcribing on his own.

Okay.

How can Jan solve problems if he runs into problems during the transcribing (for instance, if he cannot understand what is said)? He has to figure this out on his own (hear recordings multiple times on different days). At the end, Jan can make a list of all problems he had and sends this to Chris.

Let's make a file where you share the notes from the transcribing process per response, that way we can document potential ambiguities.

If the problem involves that another person has to hear the segment and Chris decides that it is highly important to solve this issue, Jan shows Chris the respective segment. If it is judges as not being highly important, Jan makes a comment in the transcript file that he was not able to identify the word (or the other problem he had).

That sounds like a good plan. This should also be in the notes then.

If Jan thinks that this is an clearly identifying information, he replaces as much information as needed with "[deleted due to anynomity reasons]". If Jan is unsure about whether an information is an identifying information, he marks this and asks Chris about it (using the transcript, not the original recording). Chris doublecheckes every transcript and replaces every potential identifying information with "[deleted due to anynomity reasons]". If Chris thinks that the replacement of an information by Jan was unnecessary, he discusses the case with Jan. If Chris afterwards still thinks that the replacement was unnecessary, he informs Jan about this and Jan replaces the "[deleted due to anynomity reasons]" with the respective information.

Great. Ibidem wrt notes.

from 2015ori-1.