Should encapsulated decisions of a decision service include output decisions? about tck HOT 7 CLOSED

I believe the list of encapsulated decisions does not contain the output decisions.

Have a look at Figure 11 (page 26) from DMN 1.1.

Output Decisions: Decision 1
Encapsulated Decisions: Decision 2
Input Data: Input data 1, Input data 2

Hope this helps.

from tck.

Is that sufficient? Should we close this?

from tck.

@opatrascoiu I think you mean Figure 10 on page 26. In Figure 11 the decision service has only a single decision.

The description of Figure 10 is on page 25, last paragraph: "The encapsulated decisions are therefore {Decision1, Decision2}."

We think that the description of Figure 10 is wrong. As you mentioned, the encapsulated decisions should only be Decision2.

from tck.

I raised an issue in OMG Jira. It is currently in their INBOX.

from tck.

https://issues.omg.org/browse/DMN12-271

from tck.

Proposal to change DMN specification:

Change the following sentence in DMN 1.1, Table 20, Row encapsulatedDecisions:
"If present, this attribute lists the instances of Decision to be
encapsulated in this DecisionService"

to the following sentence:
"If present, this attribute lists the instances of Decision to be
encapsulated in this DecisionService. This list does not include any output decisions."

from tck.

Proposal added to OMG ticket. This issue can be closed.

from tck.