RFC: Release tags about doctrinemongodbbundle HOT 6 CLOSED

This will be difficult as the 2.0 branch is currently the sf 2.0 compatibility branch, and renaming it to 1.x will break all projects relying on deps files (i.e. most project using it). and if you don't rename it to avoid breaking the existing projects, composer will consider it as 2.0.x-dev

from doctrinemongodbbundle.

Then I suppose we're forced to start the bundle version at 2.0, use 2.1 for the mapping refactoring, and 3.0 for Symfony 2.1 compatibility.

from doctrinemongodbbundle.

I created tags for doctrine/mongodb and ODM as described above.

@stof: Per semver.org, any BC breaks in the public API necessitate a major version bump. My plan for sf2.0-pre-common-mapping was to checkout fd7ac2f (before I merged your PR), add a commit to update composer.json and then tag that as 2.0.0. The commit wouldn't appear in the 2.0 branch history, but it'd stick around in Git so long as the tag referenced it.

Then, I would need a 3.0.0 tag for the 2.0 branch head, and a 4.0.0 tag for master's head. The problem there is that the 2.0 branch now has content beyond the 2.0.0 tag (i.e. stuff from 3.0.0). This seems like a maintenance headache.

So, new proposal: tag the commit before your PR as 2.0.0-BETA1 and the current 2.0 branch head as 2.0.0-BETA2. The master head can be tagged as 3.0.0-BETA1. Thoughts?

from doctrinemongodbbundle.

It looks like old v2.0.0 and v2.0.1 tags already exist here, so we'll have to respect those.

from doctrinemongodbbundle.

There don't appear to be any BC breaks between the v2.0.1 and the point before common mapping was merged (see diff). I'm going to make a commit after fd7ac2f and tag that as v2.1.0.

The diff of the 2.0 branch since mapping refactoring was introduced isn't too large, and it's debatable if the mapping changes are public API changes. I'll tag that as v2.2.0.

The master branch has changed significantly, so I'm going to start that at v3.0.0-BETA1. Once Symfony 2.1 is released, we can move to a v3.0.0 release.

Documentation updates will follow.

from doctrinemongodbbundle.

Tags:

• https://github.com/doctrine/mongodb/tags
• https://github.com/doctrine/mongodb-odm/tags
• https://github.com/doctrine/DoctrineMongoDBBundle/tags

Documentation changes:

• Symfony 2.0: 04f82aa
• Symfony 2.1: ecbbdc1

That's a wrap.

from doctrinemongodbbundle.