Don't consider obsolete parts for swapping about fritzing-app HOT 7 CLOSED

There are a few that are obsolete but we have not added the replacedBy field to avoid breaking something. For example, the old potentiometers and probably a few otters. Not sure if we could do something to not take into account these parts.

from fritzing-app.

We could add a "None" magic value for replacedBy. Or we could add a improvedBy field, that could be utilized as a way to deprecate parts without directly obsoleting them. If we don't do anything about them, the trick to add an "obsolete" suffix to the family would still work.

from fritzing-app.

It would be great if a script does that (e.g. setting the replacedBy field to none, if it is empty) for all the parts in the obsolete folder.

from fritzing-app.

Actually that is not a lot of parts:

sgpt -s "find all .fzp files that do not have the text 'replacedBy', case insensitive"
find . -type f -name "*.fzp" -exec grep -iL "replacedBy" {} +
[E]xecute, [D]escribe, [A]bort: E
./Basic Force Sensing Resistor (FSR)_4.fzp
./pot_big_4.fzp
./Raspberry Pi 3.fzp
./basic_fsr_4.fzp
./kameleon.fzp
./pot_trimmer_6mm_4.fzp
./Textile Stretch Sensor_4.fzp
./alps-starter-pot9mm_5.fzp
./Dial Potentiometer with switch_4.fzp
./Textile Potentiometer_4.fzp
./pot_trimmer_12mm_4.fzp
./Arduino Nano.fzp
./Textile Analog Pressure Sensor_4.fzp
./pot-slider_4.fzp

from fritzing-app.

As a quick test, I remove the 'obsolete' from the family, so I could find the part to create a test sketch. Reloading the sketch now triggers the replacement mechanism, because there is a replacedby attribute. Of course no replacement can be found for "None". Fritzing shows the error message, then leaves the sketch as is.

from fritzing-app.

Maybe this needs its own issue, but I will discuss it here to start the discussion as it is related to obsoleted parts:

I noticed that a few of my students´ reports still use the old symbol for the potentiometers. This is because they do not use the bins to find the parts, they search for potentiometer in the search menu and choose one of them. And the old obsoleted potentiometers still appear in that view (probably because they do not have the replacedBy attribute).

Can we not show them in the search view? Should show first the regular parts and show the obsolete them in a subsection at the end? Should we use set replacedBy to None or similar?

from fritzing-app.

Created #4151 about the search on obsolete parts

from fritzing-app.