Many readings of zero, leading to few messages about esp8266-vindriktning-particle-sensor HOT 5 CLOSED

OK, here are some side-by-side tests. For the "problematic" Device1 (red curve), I removed two of the zero checks in the code (one in the check loop, and one in the average calculation in SerialCom.h). The "behaving" Device2 (green curve) uses your code unchanged.

The first image shows an ambient overnight test. Device1 produced nothing but zeros all night.

For the second image I placed both devices under a plastic cover (maintaining the Ikea theme), and added a bit of smoke. Both devices color-cycled from green to red and back, with Device1 transitions consistently trailing Device2 as the air quality worsened, and leading Device2 as the quality improved (as an aside, it looks as though the transitions are at about 30 and 100ug/m³).

Conclusions... I suspect both devices are "working", at least for the intended purpose of a rough traffic-light air quality display. And they'll be fine for me, too. The absolute values they report are quite different, though. I haven't looked into data sheets, but maybe there's a way to calibrate the sensor if it matters to your use case.

In terms of the mod, yes, I suggest you remove the zero-checks, as long as it doesn't break anything else!

from esp8266-vindriktning-particle-sensor.

I wonder if one could implement an auto calibration algorithm similar to what is used in some CO2 sensors:

https://www.monnit.com/support/knowledgebase/sensors/co2-auto-calibration-feature/

TL;DR:
It takes the lowest reading during a long interval (multiple days) and assumes that that must be a specific value (400ppm).

from esp8266-vindriktning-particle-sensor.

Interesting report.
Honestly, I have no idea whether or not 0ug/m³ is a plausible reading or not, however that check was only there because I didn't know that there was a checksum in there to ensure that we only store valid readings.

As that has been added with 04701b2, all those > 0 checks are obsolete and can be removed I think

from esp8266-vindriktning-particle-sensor.

Thanks again - I'll give it a try!

from esp8266-vindriktning-particle-sensor.

I know this issue is closed, but I just wanted to give you measurements for transitions, just in case they're needed somewhere - according to the user guide attached to my Vindriktning sensor here they are:

• green: 0-35 (good+low)
• orange: 36-85 (OK+medicore)
• red: 86-... (bad+high)

from esp8266-vindriktning-particle-sensor.