Resolve performance issues with multiprocess plugin about interlock HOT 6 CLOSED

Related: nodejs/node#3145

Did some further digging to see where the bottlenecks were in our use case. Grabbed the AST for lodash.js (roughly 16MB JSON) and measured the full round-trip to pass over IPC to a child process and back. Also measured (de)serialization times using both JSON and `BSON.

The results:

Stringify took 2.004831594 seconds.
Parse took 0.681263825 seconds.
BSON serialize took 0.976388723 seconds.
BSON unserialize took 0.814068171 seconds.

Starting IPC...
Child received message.
IPC round-trip took 51.384239773 seconds.

from interlock.

Further measurements are warranted, especially of Babel's parse and generate, to determine whether the gains from parallelizing the tasks is worth the cost of (de)serialization. In particular, since the (de)serialization CPU burden is equally shared between the parent and child processes, we're looking at ~1s blocking operations that will interfere (to an unknown extent) with the parent's delegation of tasks to the worker pool.

from interlock.

Would something like https://github.com/dominictarr/JSONStream help? At least this way, parsing won't block and you can spread out the streaming over the parent's event loop.

from interlock.

sending large ipc messages seems to be O(n^2) in the message length (see my comment in the related issue #3145). I've seen O(n^2) delays slip in during message reassembly, maybe worth a check.

from interlock.

Thanks @andrasq. I noticed the same thing. For now, I created a workaround using Unix sockets and BSON (de)serialization. Performance appears to scale linearly with the message size, and is likely good enough for our use case.

Stringify took 1.650871098 seconds.
Parse took 0.629973014 seconds.
BSON serialize took 0.962255679 seconds.
BSON unserialize took 0.775885246 seconds.

====== Starting Native IPC... ======
Child received message.
IPC took 50.578393824 seconds.

====== Starting BSON IPC... ======
Server bound on /tmp/interlock-ipc.sock...
Server has received connection from child process.
Child is connected to server.

Child received message.
BSON-IPC took 3.852710589 seconds.

from interlock.

Looks like the performance gains from farming out work to multiple processes is mostly cancelled out by all the serialization overhead. Going to close this for now, and pursue native extensions for performance improvements instead.

from interlock.