Unable to reproduce the performance of the pretrained checkpoint for Calvin-Sim about susie HOT 11 CLOSED

And qualitatively, the model also seems to move more erratically compared to the pretrained model.

from susie.

Hi Ping-C,

Can you un-comment line 198 of calvin-sim/calvin_models/calvin_agent/evaluation/diffusion_gc_policy.py and re-evaluate? I suspect the issue is that the policy was trained with normalized actions, but is being evaluated without the assumption that actions are normalized.

from susie.

It worked! Kevin, you are amazing!

from susie.

Hello Ping-C,
I download the diffusion model and goal conditioned policy checkpoints from https://huggingface.co/patreya/susie-calvin-checkpoints and set the values of the environment variables in eval_susie.sh,

but the result is not good :
Average successful sequence length: 0.4666666666666667
Success rates for i instructions in a row:
1: 33.3%
2: 13.3%
3: 0.0%
4: 0.0%
5: 0.0%
turn_on_led: 2 / 2 | SR: 100.0%
open_drawer: 4 / 4 | SR: 100.0%
turn_on_lightbulb: 1 / 1 | SR: 100.0%
push_blue_block_right: 0 / 1 | SR: 0.0%
rotate_blue_block_right: 0 / 1 | SR: 0.0%
lift_blue_block_slider: 0 / 1 | SR: 0.0%
lift_blue_block_table: 0 / 1 | SR: 0.0%
push_pink_block_left: 0 / 2 | SR: 0.0%
move_slider_left: 0 / 3 | SR: 0.0%
push_blue_block_left: 0 / 2 | SR: 0.0%
lift_red_block_slider: 0 / 1 | SR: 0.0%
push_red_block_left: 0 / 1 | SR: 0.0%
rotate_red_block_left: 0 / 1 | SR: 0.0%
lift_red_block_table: 0 / 1 | SR: 0.0%

I noticed that you have a high success rate in evaluating pre-trained models, so I wanted to ask if there are any other operations you perform during the evaluation besides downloading the model and modifying the paths?

The actions of the robotic arm seem strange in some tasks, and I suspect that it may be an issue with GCBC.The robotic arm has even moved outside the field of view.
I would greatly appreciate it if you could tell me how to properly evaluate pre-trained models. :)

from susie.

Hi @Ping-C and @pranavatreya ,

Can you please help me? I did the same. I am trying to train the model on CALVIN dataset ABC. when I run:

python experiments/susie/calvin/calvin_gcbc.py --config experiments/susie/calvin/configs/gcbc_train_config.py:gc_ddpm_bc --calvin_dataset_config experiments/susie/calvin/configs/gcbc_data_config.py:all

I got that error: Traceback (most recent call last): File "experiments/susie/calvin/calvin_gcbc.py", line 186, in app.run(main) File "/home/gaurav/miniconda3/envs/susie-calvin/lib/python3.8/site-packages/absl/app.py", line 308, in run run_main(main, args) File "/home/gaurav/miniconda3/envs/susie-calvin/lib/python3.8/site-packages/absl/app.py", line 254, in run_main sys.exit(main(argv)) File "experiments/susie/calvin/calvin_gcbc.py", line 77, in main task_paths = [ File "experiments/susie/calvin/calvin_gcbc.py", line 78, in glob_to_path_list( File "/media/local/gaurav/Music/calvin-sim/bridge_data_v2/jaxrl_m/data/calvin_dataset.py", line 27, in glob_to_path_list assert len(filtered_paths) > 0, f"{glob_str} came up empty" AssertionError: training/A/?/? came up empty

I ensured that the dataset is located at the path expected by the script. The glob pattern training/A/?/? suggests it's looking for directories or files within training/A/ where each subdirectory in A has a single-character name. so what should I do?

I will appreciate your help. Thanks in advance!
Have you converted the dataset into tfrecord format?

from susie.

@houyaokun Hi, have you solved the problem? I am struggling with the same issue. 😭

from susie.

@houyaokun Hi, have you solved the problem? I am struggling with the same issue. 😭

yeah，os.environ.pop("DISPLAY") may work.

from susie.

@houyaokun Thank you for your quick reply. 😄 Actually, I am having problem with reproduction. My results are so bad with the provided pre-trained models. How did you handle this problem? Thank you so much for your reply. I am struggling with this about a week.

from susie.

@Ping-C Hi, I am struggling with the performance. I did all things same as they told me to do. But the performance is bad on provided pre-trained models. How did you reproduce? Is there anything else I need to do besides the default settings?

from susie.

@houyaokun Thank you for your quick reply. 😄 Actually, I am having problem with reproduction. My results are so bad with the provided pre-trained models. How did you handle this problem? Thank you so much for your reply. I am struggling with this about a week.
For me,I simply added os.environ.pop("DISPLAY") .By doing this, you will be able to use EGL normally. Otherwise, you will have a domain gap between the images in the dataset (rendered with EGL)

from susie.

So the problem is domain gap with dataset. I will take a closer look at the rendering part.
Thank you so much for your reply. Hope you have a wonderful day. 😃

from susie.