Enable library for Linux on Z (s390x) about mirage-crypto HOT 5 CLOSED

We won't be adding support to a crypto library for something we cannot ensure the quality of on an ongoing basis. @edelsohn, would you mind emailing me on [email protected] about this request? We need access to a reasonable number of Z cores (not the tiny free plan) in order to do end-to-end package builds.

When I enquired last year, I was emailed by [email protected] on 2nd Dec 2020 who said:

We have a number of options to access s390x systems for academic, research, and open source community projects. Let me pull a few of our technical resources together to better understand your project and requirements so we can look at various options. I will get back to you to schedule a call once I have identified the colleagues to include.

And then she stopped responding altogether despite multiple emails from me.

I don't have the capacity to chase up anyone through the IBM organisation. If you have someone else who could get us access to a stable, and reasonable number of cores to do bulk package builds, then we can support Z. By comparison, we have ~1000 cores in our x86 build pool, and ~400 in our arm64 pool (WorksOnArm/equinix-metal-arm64-cluster#279), and ~160 in our ppc64le pool. These would be available for all OCaml package builds, not just mirage-crypto.

from mirage-crypto.

Are the numbers of "cores" referring to hardware threads or to processor cores? I suspect that they refer to hardware threads as shown by Linux /proc/cpuinfo. There is a big difference.

Also, s390x systems have different performance characteristics from other systems, so forecasting resource requirements based on x86 systems is not accurate. Starting a conversation with "we want 100's or 1000's of s390x cores" is not productive.

from mirage-crypto.

I'm happy to work with the OCaml community to provide long-term access to Linux on s390x systems. I sent you private email.

from mirage-crypto.

Update: I've got a VM now and am getting the base image builder hooked up. A manual run has succeeded with OCaml 4.12 images, so it should be straightforward.

from mirage-crypto.

thanks for your issue, and your pull request that I just merged. I opened a new issue, #131 with further s390x improvements.

from mirage-crypto.