yaml mapping support? about imposm3 HOT 7 CLOSED

Although I like the idea of writing yaml instead of json, I don't think it is a particularly great idea to maintain two different systems.

from imposm3.

I don't know go details, but in general yaml can map to json like structure, so it should only be a matter of having two parsers that ends up to the same structure, no?

from imposm3.

It is indeed very easy to map yaml and json onto a struct in Go (yaml would need an additional dependency, but that's a rather minor problem). I just think that it might be a case of unnecessary over-complication for a tool that is supposed to do one thing right.

from imposm3.

ok ok, let's count my { and } so ;)

(Closing as there is no call for action, but debate is still possible.)

from imposm3.

Imposm 3 uses JSON because it is supported by Go's stdlib and was easy to integrate. JSON itself is horrible for a configuration format, since it doesn't support comments. I won't mind switching to YAML.

All valid JSON is also valid YAML, so a switch to YAML with the same mapping structure will still read "old" imposm mappings. Question is: does go-yaml support the same mapping?

from imposm3.

Hello,
I'm working on a conversion of the OSM CartoCSS style (with YAML). But I've some problems, maybe it's related to import error? Look at the image please.

Info: Hannover / Bemerode (Germany)

A road should be a LINESTRING and not an area so maybe there is a problem regarding the geometry of many roads or with IMPOSM3?

from imposm3.

@tds4u I think you should open a new issue, because I don't see that your post is related to this thread.

from imposm3.