Cannot pick value from object if key contains dot about dot-object HOT 4 CLOSED

A key with dots is ambiguous, e.g how should this work:

const object = {
  foo: {
    bar: 'baz',
  },
 'foo.bar': 'baz,
}

Perhaps adding an escape makes sense? (not currently supported)

dot.pick('foo\.bar', object)

from dot-object.

I do not think that escaping would make sense since some strings and objects may come from an external source that is not aware of the plugin.

How about this:

const object = {
    foo: {
        bar: 'one'
    }
    'foo.bar': 'two',
    'some.thing': 'three'
};

dot.pick('foo.bar', object); // "one"
dot.pick('some.thing', object); // "three"
object['foo.bar']; // "two"

We could prefer sub-properties to dotted properties since they are way more frequent. So, if there is an ambiguous situation, this would need additional code by the developer. And I think that it would be simpler to implement.

As soon as the property cannot be resolved, we go with the next iteration and concatenate the previous key with the current one.

from dot-object.

Perhaps it's better to solve it in your own code:

const value = object['foo.bar'] || dot.pick('foo.bar', object);

For the other methods like set, move transfer etc. the behavior would become rather unpredictable.

from dot-object.

Sorry to reopen this here:

@rhalff you mention "it's better to solve it in your own code" but we don't always know the object schema.
Is it possible to implement the following?

const object = {
    foo: {
        bar: 'one'
    },
    'foo.bar': 'two',
    'some': {
        'other.node': {
            is: 'three'
        }
    }
}

let value = dot.pick('some["other.node"].is', object);

// three

This is similar to what I would do in code, and it should cover scenarios where the property has spaces and characters that might be used as alternative separators https://github.com/rhalff/dot-object#using-a-different-separator

This could work interchangeably, even for non-dotted properties:

dot.pick('foo.bar', object) === dot.pick('["foo"]["bar"]', object)

dot.pick('["foo.bar"]', object) === object["foo.bar"]

from dot-object.