Feature request: remove CREATE PRIVATE/PUBLIC when ABSTRACT about abap-cleaner HOT 3 OPEN

This would only be relevant when the class is also FINAL, right?

(Also, relevant issue from the past: #104 )

from abap-cleaner.

Let me get back to this before the thread becomes stale :)

I do agree with the need to differentiate between FINAL and non-FINAL.
as in: Sometimes, the create public is needed, sometimes it can be removed as not needed.
as in: Somtimes, the exporting argument in a method call is needed, sometimes it can be removed as not needed :)

So I am voting for having an option in one of the rules to remove the create public if not needed, and that is if it is a abstract final class.

from abap-cleaner.

Hi PhiL,

as mentioned by ConjuringCoffee, CREATE PUBLIC would still make sense for an abstract non-final class, because this information is then inherited by its subclasses:

• if the superclass is ABSTRACT CREATE PUBLIC and the subclass does not explicitly specify a more restricted CREATE level, the subclass can't declare its constructor in the PROTECTED SECTION, otherwise you get a syntax error.
• if you then change the superclass(!) to CREATE PROTECTED, the syntax error in the subclass is gone.

By contrast, for an ABSTRACT FINAL class, no constructor can be declared anywhere, so as far as I can see, you're right that CREATE {PUBLIC|PROTECTED|PRIVATE} could be removed in such a case. I could just imagine this to be a hint in the sense of "for now, we'll prevent instantiation of this class, but if we ever change our minds and remove the FINAL, we then want the class to be CREATE PUBLIC" (but that may be a bit far-fetched…)

Therefore, not entirely sure what to do with this. One argument that came up in a different place is that unfortunately, ABAP classes are by default CREATE PUBLIC (while CREATE PRIVATE would be desirable to enforce static CREATE methods with good, semantic names); therefore, you should keep CREATE PUBLIC in the code as a reminder that the class design is not yet ideal. (But admittedly, that's a different story).

Kind regards,
Jörg-Michael

from abap-cleaner.