Sha256sum not working on MacOS about makefile.venv HOT 6 CLOSED

Yeah... macOS does not ship GNU coreutils by default, you need to install them via brew or in some other way. That makes me wonder, which make implementation is shipped by default (if any)? Could you paste the output of make --version?

I am hesitant to change installation instructions as you suggested, because calling Perl to calculate a hash sum instead of using coreutils feels deeply wrong to me. I think I'll add a note about coreutils and mention your workaround too.

from makefile.venv.

Output for make --version:

GNU Make 3.81
Copyright (C) 2006  Free Software Foundation, Inc.
This is free software; see the source for copying conditions.
There is NO warranty; not even for MERCHANTABILITY or FITNESS FOR A
PARTICULAR PURPOSE.

This program built for i386-apple-darwin11.3.0

By the way, may I ask why not using coreutils is bad?

from makefile.venv.

Oh, it's not bad and it's not about coreutils per se. It just feels wrong to me to call into interpreted language for a number-crunching task when there exists a compiled binary tool for the same purpose.

from makefile.venv.

Personally, I don't think the performance loss is really significant, since the file Makefile.venv isn't really big. Yet, if shasum is shipped with all Linux distributions plus MacOS, so why not use it?

Apologise if I ask a stupid question!

from makefile.venv.

Your question is not stupid :) I'm being somewhat irrational here, you're right about performance being similar for small files. I'm being too much of a GNU fanboy :)

I'll look into how ubiquitous Perl currently is. I'll check if common Docker containers ship with Perl included, since it's the only scenario I could think of that's questionable. Then I will take a 1-2 day pause to let this sink in, but yeah, the rational thing would be to agree with you.

from makefile.venv.

My intuition proved correct. shasum is not included into any of base Docker images (Alpine, Debian, Ubuntu, Centos). Even though shasum is part of Perl package, deb-based distros provide a smaller perl-base (without shasum) which is enough for OS tools to function.

On the other hand, GNU coreutils are present in each of those images.

I'll add a note about macOS to README now, but the instructions should stay unchanged.

from makefile.venv.