Lead is returning hash instead of object about closeio HOT 7 CLOSED

Sorry about that the README docs were outdated as of the 3.x version.

Responses in 3.x return a hash instead of a Hashie::Mash object used previously.

from closeio.

Why move from Hashie::Mash to hash? This significantly breaks our integration if we upgrade to 3.x and is preventing us from upgrading until we have a chance to revert to the uglier hash syntax. In fact, its not just dot notation that's an issue. We use symbols as hash keys which worked with Hashie::Mash. Now, Close returns a hash with string keys.

If it's just to remove the dependency on Hashie::Mash, it would be nice to let us opt in as we already have this dependency on our application.

from closeio.

I changed my version to 2.6.10 and it worked as per documentation i.e lead.contacts

from closeio.

@synth Yep, it was to remove the dependency. We're following SemVer so it shouldn't be a surprise there are breaking changes.

from closeio.

Too bad. This is a regression in usability imo. Also, SemVer doesn't mean that just because you can have breaking changes across major versions, that we should expect them all the time. I didn't see any documentation on this anywhere - so yea, it was a surprise that took digging through this libraries source to figure out.

from closeio.

Yeah, I could've probably done a release that deprecated Hashie, but still left an option to use it as response middleware. Then fully removed it in the next release -- that would've been a good usability experience.

You're also right there is not any documentation in CHANGELOG.md, I apologize for that and will ensure future releases are documented properly.

I'm trying to think back to my original intent as to why I removed it -- it was two years ago, so hard to remember... I think it was a knee-jerk reaction to these:

• https://www.schneems.com/2014/12/15/hashie-considered-harmful.html
• https://code.dblock.org/2017/02/24/the-demonic-possession-of-hashie-mash.html

Plus my experience in memory bloat in the applications I was maintaining at the time. I know it's not helpful for the situation you're in, but hopefully it provides some context.

from closeio.

Gotcha, thanks for the explanation.

from closeio.