Internal Telegram bot API tokens about telegram-bot-api HOT 9 CLOSED

What are you calling "API keys"?

from telegram-bot-api.

What are you calling "API keys"?

Sorry for confusing, I mean Telegram bot API token

from telegram-bot-api.

@JulyIghor, in easier words, you are suggesting to create a Telegram bot API (for a certain bot) and asking, won't it interfere with the work of Telegram bots API? If I understand you correctly, I'm pretty sure you don't want to use this project for that. You can consider this project a proxy between your bot and Telegram servers (you can find many more details about what local bot API is and what it can be used for in #1). So it seems to be technically possible to do what you want (at least I don't see anything preventing you from doing this), but why not make it a part of a bot itself? If you want to make your bot of many pieces which should be seen by Telegram as one bot with one token, just implement such one bot and give it one token

from telegram-bot-api.

@JulyIghor, in easier words, you are suggesting to create a Telegram bot API (for a certain bot) and asking, won't it interfere with the work of Telegram bots API? If I understand you correctly, I'm pretty sure you don't want to use this project for that. You can consider this project a proxy between your bot and Telegram servers (you can find many more details about what local bot API is and what it can be used for in #1). So it seems to be technically possible to do what you want (at least I don't see anything preventing you from doing this), but why not make it a part of a bot itself? If you want to make your bot of many pieces which should be seen by Telegram as one bot with one token, just implement such one bot and give it one token

I wish to automate creating new API tokens for new bots without t.me/BotFather and store them in own DB.
Each of my bots doing different job for different channels, but using the same @ bot name.
And I wish all my bot services to not have access to a API tokens used by other bots and restrict them by allowed rights.

Yes, of course I can do own service to handle all of that, but since this project is a proxy, it would be great to have possibility of creating some proxy filter rules with a custom local API tokens database.

from telegram-bot-api.

@JulyIghor sounds better with a more detailed explanation but seems to be a very specific problem... I don't think it will ever be available out of the box

from telegram-bot-api.

@JulyIghor sounds better with a more detailed explanation but seems to be a very specific problem... I don't think it will ever be available out of the box

It is more a feature request than a problem. And it would make some bot servers more secure.
It could work similar to a local BotFather per stored API tokens to create new local API tokens.
For now I see the only usage of current release to break 50Mb file upload limit and I think we need more features here.

from telegram-bot-api.

I think we need more features here

I think the main scope of this project is not to push people to use their own self-hosted instance by providing a more feature-rich alternative to the telegram-hosted bot api, rather it's to give an alternative/solution to people who need to overcome certain limits or to those who require a custom implementation, for some reasons. Something you can work on to fit your needs. I don't think this project was ever meant to compete with api.telegram.org - also considering Telegram's API is running on this same exact code - so I don't know how the maintainer feels about this, but I feel like deriving too much from what is the set of features offered by the official bot api is a bit out of the scope. Just my two cents. Anyone can still fork this project and add an additional bearer auth-like authentication

from telegram-bot-api.

@JulyIghor You can do that if you fork the project and add this funtionality. It doesn't sound hard to implement, but it is out of the scope of this repository.

from telegram-bot-api.

@JulyIghor You can do that if you fork the project and add this funtionality. It doesn't sound hard to implement, but it is out of the scope of this repository.

ok, thanks for the info

from telegram-bot-api.