redundant spec labels? about w3c.github.io HOT 5 CLOSED

For me, a bug is something that is broken, while an enhancement is an aspect that works but could/should be improved. Yes, every change is an enhancement, in some way (or you wouldn't make it) but I think that's a common convention.

And substantive and bug aren't exclusive, I think: bugs can be trivial, substantive, catastrophic… And enhancements, too.

from w3c.github.io.

@tripu

For me, a bug is something that is broken, while an enhancement is an aspect that works but could/should be improved.

Fair enough. Can we have slightly more explicit labels, given that there isn't any documentation in the issues system of github? Or should we just document the labels somewhere for the first time people are looking at them? (Hello maintenance)

from w3c.github.io.

I guess we could be more specific on https://w3c.github.io/spec-labels.html, yes. Although for me that suffices as a general recommendation: groups end up with their own conventions, and the exact meaning of labels will vary depending on the nature of the repo, etc.

from w3c.github.io.

@plehegar, I'd close this one when #34 is merged

from w3c.github.io.

I propose we close this one now.

from w3c.github.io.