TkK findings about awg-app HOT 13 OPEN

M317

• M 317 Sk4 T. 3B-6:
  • doubled svgGroupId "g10030" for m. 6, sys. 3-4, and m. 6, sys. 4 ("fis1 durch Einkreisung getilgt"), probably wrong in second case
• M 317 Sk4 T. 7-12:
  • Missing tkk entry for tkk-group m. 12, sys. 8: [xx] ? Or too many classes? (order of svg elements)
• M 317 Sk4 T. 13-15:
  • Missing tkk entry for tkk-group m. 13, sys. 15,16: rests ? Or too many classes? (order of svg elements)
  • Missing tkk entry for tkk-group m. 14, sys. 16: [xx] ? Or too many classes? (order of svg elements)
• M317 Sk3.1.3:
  • Linkbox grouping for all link boxes missing?
  • In SVGs, this sketch includes system 5 (because of the "Strich mit unklarer Bedeutung."). Sys, 5 not declared in SourceDescription.
• M317 Sk3.1:
  • Nested tkk groups g1225 in g1241 works, but will not be rendered properly
  • Linkbox grouping for Sk1 missing
  • Link to C:Sk1 not correct (in comment for m. {5}, sys. 4, 6/8)
• M317 Sk3.1.2:
  • Linkbox grouping for Sk1 missing
• M317 Sk1:
  • Linkbox grouping for Sk2.1.3 missing

from awg-app.

M 317 Sk 4, Missing tkk entry for tkk-group m. 14, sys. 16:
##looks fine to me. what is wrong?

M317 Sk3.1, Link to C:Sk1 not correct (in comment for m. {5}, sys. 4, 6/8):
##looks fine to me, what is wrong?

M317 Sk3.1.3, Linkbox grouping for all link boxes missing?:
##big mystery... grouping exists, sth is wrong anyway.

for the other findings in M317 see PR #852

from awg-app.

M 317 Sk 4, Missing tkk entry for tkk-group m. 14, sys. 16:
##looks fine to me. what is wrong?

The SVG viewer displays a tkk-box for "u. von u. 3 sowie Winkel mit rotem Buntstift." which is correct, but another (smaller) tkk-box inside it around the "u. 3". But there is no separate tkk for that location. So wether the tkk comment is missing or there is an additional misplaced tkk-class in the SVG file.

M317 Sk3.1, Link to C:Sk1 not correct (in comment for m. {5}, sys. 4, 6/8):
##looks fine to me, what is wrong?

Yes, seems to be fine for me, too. Probably there was some issue before the latest release, but it seems to be gone.

from awg-app.

I see. M 317 Sk4 should be fixed now (update PR #852).

from awg-app.

M317 Sk3.1.3, Linkbox grouping for all link boxes missing?:
##big mystery... grouping exists, sth is wrong anyway.

just a guess: this is the only item so far with linkbox grouping + "rowtable": true, might this cause the issue?

from awg-app.

I don't think so. But I recognized that in other files there is a group with an aria-label for the linkBox label within the g.link-box , something like:

<g
       aria-label="Sk2.1"
       id="text110"
       style="font-weight: 700; font-size: 12px; font-family: Arial-BoldMT, Arial;  isolation: isolate;  fill: #7d7d7d;"
       class="cls-13"> ...

This is missing for all link-boxes in Sk3.1.3

from awg-app.

M30 & M34

• M 34 Sk 1

  • Missing svgGroupId (and class in svg?) for m. 1, sys. 2, 3/4: Viertelnote gestrichen

• M 30 Sk1

  • T. {9D-12B}

    • m. {9D-12B} in SVG vs. m. {9D–10D, 11B}, 12B in sourceDesc

  • T. 7B -{10C}:

    • Des (?) in: {
      "svgGroupId": "g1156",
      "measure": "9C",
      "system": "11",
      "position": "1. Note",
      "comment": "des gestrichen."
      },

  • T. 9E-{15B}

    • {13B–15B} (?) in: {
      "svgGroupId": "g1197",
      "measure": "{13B–14B}",
      "system": "14–15",
      "position": "",
      "comment": "Takte pauschal gestrichen."
      },

  • T. 17–21

    • [b]b2 ... [a]g2 (?) in: {
      "svgGroupId": "g1131",
      "measure": "19",
      "system": "1",
      "position": "6/8",
      "comment": "b² überschreibt g²."
      },

  • T. 25–29B

    • [a]a1 ... [b]ges1(?) in: {
      "svgGroupId": "g1108",
      "measure": "27",
      "system": "7",
      "position": "4. Note",
      "comment": "a¹ überschreibt ges¹."
      },
    • class and groupId in SVG missing for {
      "svgGroupId": "g37",
      "measure": "{28A–29A}",
      "system": "7",
      "position": "",
      "comment": "Noten pauschal gestrichen."
      },

from awg-app.

M212 TF 1

• p. 1

  • The first tkk in m.1 has as location: (2/8) bis Taktende for the hairpin, but the crescendo hairpin ends at 2/4 ?

• p. 2

  • The tkk for m. 14, 1/8, and (now) m. 14 1/8 (but probably m. 23, see below) dispaly accidentals in brackets. Correct? //TA: correct!
  • There is no tkk displayed on the very last asterisk m. 23, but a second tkk displayed in m. 14, lower piano, that reads: 14 | Klav. | 1/8 | (♯) zu Gis1/Cis und (♮) zu H/g als redundant weggelassen. B: Akkoladenwechsel nach T. 22. which is probably the missing tkk for m. 23?

• SourceDescription:

  • Description mixes Flecke and Flecken for plural forms.
  • FirmSign mentioned, but no image/type included?
  • Die Korrekturen in <strong>B</strong>B betreffen Textfassung 2. Probably without the repeated B ? (ping @masthom since added after your PR)
  • Wouldn't add a line break in the title description

line breaks also in op. 25 source A (Taktzahlen, Instrumentenvorsatz)!?
for the other points see #910

• Tkk class and group id missing for

                   "svgGroupId": "",
                   "measure": "18",
                   "system": "Ges.",
                   "position": "1. Note",
                   "comment": "Text sic: (Ver-)storb(-nen) ohne Binnen-Apostroph. Rosegger_PM: Verstorb’nen."
               },

from awg-app.

Op. 22 SkRT

• SourceDescription:

  • Writing Material mentions 3 types of sheets, but refers only to "Bl. 1" and "Bl. 2"
  • Also: correct that the "shortest" sheet type has 9 systems, and the longer ones have only 8 systems?

• SkRTc

  • Last tkk on row variant 47 had: Bl. 3r | 8a | Ub. Corrected to Ud according to SourceDescription and transcription, correct?

from awg-app.

Op. 27 SkRT

• SkRTa:

  • Row form Ges should be Kgis (?) in
    Bl. 1r | 1b | Ges: 10.–11. Reihenton | Auf Rasur: vermutlich ♭b1–♮h1 geändert zu ♭b–♮h.

• SkRTb:

  • Tkk for second dividing line is missing (but duplicates svg id and content of that in SkRTa = C&P error?):
    Bl. 2r | 1b–8b | K- und KU-Formen: 6.–7. Reihenton | Strich zur Gliederung der Hexachorde mit rotem Buntstift. Vermutlich nachträglich gezogen, da der Strich mit einzelnen Notenköpfen kollidiert.
  • Kd should be Ka (?) in
    Bl. 2r | 1b | Kd | Reihennummerierung 18 mit grünem Buntstift.

from awg-app.