Long-standing repaint-flicker issue. about terminal.gui HOT 8 OPEN

@BDisp if you're going to look into making Clip more sophisticated, I found the PR I thought I lost where I started down that path:

#2606

Nevermind. That branch does not have all the really awesome code I wrote in it. I must have never pushed. Long gone. Sad.

from terminal.gui.

I'm done trying to debug this flicker thing for now. So frustrating!

That's true, it's really frustrating. I have also analyzed the cause and I am almost certain that it is necessary to limit the drawing of decorations to their thickness. It could also be someone from Label at Border who is cleaning outside of his area.

Note that in #3323, someone has to directly set Driver.Clip to cause Driver.AddRune or Driver.FIllRect to do any drawing outside of Viewport.

The only code still in the library (outside of ViewDrawing.cs that still does that is:

Based on this, I'm skeptical it has to do with someone clearing outside of their Viewport.

from terminal.gui.

@BDisp if you're going to look into making Clip more sophisticated, I found the PR I thought I lost where I started down that path:

#2606

from terminal.gui.

I'm done trying to debug this flicker thing for now. So frustrating!

That's true, it's really frustrating. I have also analyzed the cause and I am almost certain that it is necessary to limit the drawing of decorations to their thickness. It could also be someone from Label at Border who is cleaning outside of his area.

from terminal.gui.

@BDisp if you're going to look into making Clip more sophisticated, I found the PR I thought I lost where I started down that path:

#2606

I've seen it, but it has a lot of unrelated changes and I'd rather start from scratch.

from terminal.gui.

I have already made the changes to use an array of Rectangles and the same problem continues to persist.
Using conhost directly from VS2022 this flickering does not happen, even though we are using True Color. Just using Windows Terminal this flickering continues and I already suspect if it is a problem with it.
Still, do you want me to submit a PR with the changes to Driver.Clip?

from terminal.gui.

I have already made the changes to use an array of Rectangles and the same problem continues to persist. Using conhost directly from VS2022 this flickering does not happen, even though we are using True Color. Just using Windows Terminal this flickering continues and I already suspect if it is a problem with it. Still, do you want me to submit a PR with the changes to Driver.Clip?

I don't think an array of Rectangles is the right approach. I think we want to build the next-gen clipping support on a Region class that is either directly this:

https://learn.microsoft.com/en-us/dotnet/api/system.drawing.region?view=dotnet-plat-ext-8.0

Or, is a clone of it.

So, unless you built your experiment on Region, no.

from terminal.gui.

I don't think an array of Rectangles is the right approach. I think we want to build the next-gen clipping support on a Region class that is either directly this:

https://learn.microsoft.com/en-us/dotnet/api/system.drawing.region?view=dotnet-plat-ext-8.0

Or, is a clone of it.

So, unless you built your experiment on Region, no.

By chance I noticed the Region class but I didn't use it to avoid having to add another library. I created a RectangleExtensions class to manipulate its Rectangle methods with the array. But since it didn't solve the problem with flickering and I didn't use the Region class, I'm going to give up on continuing with my PR.

from terminal.gui.