Hi,

We are using cool powermail extension with recaptcha. To make it work, we enabled spamshield. Now, when I enter all required fields, except the recaptcha one, I get this message in FE >

As user, I would be confused that I have to set checkbox at recaptcha to be able to send form. Maybe this could be improved?

thx
Florian

The language of message displayed on the captcha box seems to be determined by browser language. Is it possible to force this setup based on the webpage language?

Using in ex. something like
plugin.tx_powermailrecaptcha.lang = fr

Thank you in advance for your help.
Regards,

How would one display parsley error messages on this captcha integration? By default I get no error message. If I check the "mandatory field" box in the backend then at least I get an error after the page submit, but no matter if the capcha is valid or not it always tell me that there is no value sent.

This is my current custom implementation:

<div class="field {vh:Validation.ErrorClass(field:field, class:'error')} powermail_fieldwrap powermail_fieldwrap_type_recaptcha powermail_fieldwrap_{field.marker} {field.css} {settings.styles.framework.fieldAndLabelWrappingClasses}">
	<label class="{settings.styles.framework.labelClasses}" title="{field.description}">
		<vh:string.RawAndRemoveXss>{field.title}</vh:string.RawAndRemoveXss><span class="mandatory">*</span>
	</label>
	<div class="row bottom-xs">
		<div class="col-xs-12 col-sm-6">
			<f:if condition="{settings.recaptcha.sitekey} != 'abcdef'">
				<f:then>
					<script src="//www.google.com/recaptcha/api.js" async defer></script>
					<div class="g-recaptcha" data-sitekey="{settings.recaptcha.sitekey}" data-parsley-errors-container=".powermail_field_error_container_{field.marker}"></div>
				</f:then>
				<f:else>
					<p>
						Please register your domain to
						<a href="https://www.google.com/recaptcha/">https://www.google.com/recaptcha/</a>
						and enter your sitekey in TypoScript Constants like<br />
						plugin.tx_powermailrecaptcha.sitekey = abcdef
					</p>
				</f:else>
			</f:if>
		</div>
		<div class="col-xs-12 col-sm-6">
			<div class="powermail_field_error_container_{field.marker}"></div>
			<f:form.validationResults>
				<f:if condition="{validationResults.flattenedErrors}">
					<f:for each="{validationResults.flattenedErrors}" as="errors">
						<f:for each="{errors}" as="singleError">
							<f:if condition="{field.marker} == {singleError.code}">
								<p class="error">
									<f:translate key="validationerror_{singleError.message}">{singleError.message}</f:translate>
								</p>
							</f:if>
						</f:for>
					</f:for>
				</f:if>
			</f:form.validationResults>
		</div>
	</div>
</div>

I've tried to target the div that should display the error messages with data-parsley-errors-container=".powermail_field_error_container{field.marker}"_. This works great for any other input (text, select, integrated captcha, etc) but not for powermailrecaptcha. The line <f:form.validationResults> is there just to show validation errors for this field it js is disabled or parsley is not used.

We have installed and configured the extension as described. Unfortunately, there is no "Google Captcha" in Powermail form fields.

We are currently using Typo3 7.6.15 and Powermail 3.11.1

On upgrading a project, I just saw that I can't really install this extension because of the dependencies to powermail v8. Is there any plan on an update in the near future?

Hello, great work btw.
Can you help me how to add multiple recaptcha on same page.
i have tab(4) content element and first 2 tabs are powermail forms, but when i set recaptcha on both forms i get error multiple loading source on same page for recaptcha.
Is there a way to add dynamically id in template of recaptcha, then we can remove line from template for calling api and assign it to page.includeJS as external source. So we can have multiple recaptcha but one call to api.

Thanks!

Hi there,
first of all, great work, it's really easy to install for noobs like me :D
but I have a problem, somehow the sitekey doesn't get delivered. I pasted the key in the ext_typoscript_setup.txt file, but the frontend gives "Please register you domain.. bla bla.. plugin.tx_powermailrecaptcha.sitekey = abcdef"
I hardcoded a {settings.recaptcha.sitekey} in the < p > tag in the .html file and it outputs "abcdef", so the link to it is broken. I'm a complete beginner in typo3, and the coding world too, but I like challenges. I'm trying to understand how your code works, how typoscript works and where exactly is the value saved. If i get to the bottom of it, I will write my fix here. A bit of help understanding how it works or what I should do would be great.
Thanks!

Hi

While implementing this extension into a project, we found that the current way of handling the configurations could be improved.

Right now, the defaults are in ext_typoscript_constants.txt and ext_typoscript_setup.txt (for which I could not find any documentation btw, are these following any core convention?). The problem with the current loading of configuration is that the loading order can't be affected in any way as the extension configuration itself is always loaded "at the end"; One can't override the settings in a custom project-specific extension's configuration that is being loaded through \TYPO3\CMS\Core\Utility\ExtensionManagementUtility::addTypoScriptSetup(). It only works so far if we put the configuration directly into a db-based sys_template record.

Additionally, as credentials should not be in a VCS anyway, we thought that we might be able to load the configuration via .env, as the API keys might be environment-specific. This would allow changing them without touching the database.

Maybe a nice improvement step would be to actually use ext_emconf_template.txt / get the configuration from the EXTENSIONS array from e. g. LocalConfiguration.php / AdditionalConfiguration.php which then would allow to set the API keys via .env, and it would also allow to override configuration in a project extension as described above, without it ignoring the desired loading order.

What do you think?

Is powermail 7.4.0 supported and tested?

In Readme.md it says:

Dependencies
powermail >= 5.0 and < 7.0

In composer.json it says:

"in2code/powermail": ">=5.0.0 <8.0.0"

I activated and integrated the captcha. It is also displayed. Unfortunately I had a flood of spam today.

Problem could be that you can send the form (at least some) without filling in the captcha.

The captcha is created. sitekey / secret set. It is marked as a mandatory field.

If it doesn't work you can send the form without captcha.

What could be the reason?

I run typo3 8.7.24 latest powermail and latest captcha

Thanks in advance.

Hi,
When i submit a basic form, after the confirmation page, it gives me this error

Without confirmation page, everything is fine tho
Note: I have the same error with the jh_captcha extension, any idea?
Thanks

Do you plan an update of your extension in the near future?

Is it planned to integrate the new "invisible reCAPTCHA" for Powermail? That would be great.

https://developers.google.com/recaptcha/docs/invisible
Thanks

There will be an EXT:powermailrecaptcha version, which is compatible with TYPO3 core V12. It is currently under development and testing.

If you need early access to this version, please head over to https://www.in2code.de/agentur/typo3-extensions/early-access-programm/ and support our work.

When installing with composer we get the following message:

The TYPO3 extension package "in2code/powermailrecaptcha", does not define an extension key in its composer.json. Please report this to the author of this package. Specifying the extension key will be mandatory i
n future versions of TYPO3 (see: https://docs.typo3.org/m/typo3/reference-coreapi/master/en-us/ExtensionArchitecture/ComposerJson/Index.html#extra)

After I migrated from "rh_recaptcha" I encountered the problem of a missing custom message like "Please solve the Captcha!" instead of the default spam faktor message.

I don't see a possibility to determine the spamcheck failed because of the recaptcha...

This may leads to a conceptional issue up to powermail itself, would be a great feature to alternatively define custom validation messages yourself for fields in general.

Greetings
Daniel

https://github.com/einpraegsam/powermailrecaptcha/blob/6220109c81bc5d113517ef9e15769364fe53fba2/Classes/Domain/Validator/SpamShield/RecaptchaMethod.php#L110

I think you should consider the case that a recaptcha validation is unnecessary or even worse may lead to errors when called from the optinAction. I would like to suggest to add that case to the condition like so:

return ($this->getActionName() === 'create' && $confirmationActive) || $this->getActionName() === 'optinConfirm';

Hi,
please update the TYPO3 dependency in composer.json from typo3/cms -> typo3/cms-core
thx!

Hello there,

It seems that the composer json still has version 1.0.1 and therefore is not deployed correctly to packagist. Could you update this?

Best Regards
Luca