Landed titles for which I can't find a Latin/Greek/any other ancient analogue about bp HOT 22 OPEN

@Freudensonne: I checked earlier and it wasn't represented. I just checked again and b_qasr_ash-shams is the only place on the latest code branch that is named Paraetonium/Paraitonion.

from bp.

Qasr Ash-Shams: Ptolemy (121-151 A.D.), in his book “Geography”, mentions a town named Babylon which existed from Pharaonic times on part of a site of what is now included in Cairo.

A canal ran through this town connecting the Nile with the Red Sea. Roman Emperor Trajan (98-117 A.D.) reopened this canal and also enlarged and equipped a fortress which was located at the southern end of the town. The fortress, known as the “Castle of Babylon”, or “Castle of Egypt” (Khemi), was further enlarged by Emperor Arcadius (395-408 A.D.). There was a fluvial port at this location where ships could anchor. In 335 A.D., the Roman Emperor altered shipping routes from Alexandria to the Babylon fortress. The area of Old Cairo was the first nucleus of present-day Cairo.

It is not known exactly when this city became a bishopric but it must have been before the first half of the 5th century as a certain Cyrus, Bishop of Babylon, was present at the Council of Ephesus held in 449 A.D.

At the time of the Arab conquest of Egypt, Babylon seemed to have been a large city extending northwards as far as Tendounias (‘Um Dunain’), the present district of al-Azbakiah, where there was a fortified outpost. The Arab general ‛Amr Ibn al-‘As captured this outpost and occupied the city as far as the Castle of Egypt, to which he laid siege. On April 9th, 641 A.D. this castle, which the Arabs named “Qasr ash-Sham’a (wax castle) surrendered. After the Arab conquest of Egypt, the name Babylon was more commonly used to denote the district immediately around the Castle of Egypt or Qasr ash-Shams.

from bp.

Wadi Masus: supposed to be Abbasca on this map

from bp.

Um Shashoba is a name of the golden mine, the most close town (which is said to be a religious center in Pharaonic times and cross of roads to Myos Hormos and Berenike in Ptolemaic and Eastern Roman times) is Qift (Arabic name)/Gebtu (Ancient Egyptian)/Koptos (Ancient Greek name)/Justinianopolis (Roman, what was needed).

from bp.

Jabal Quzlum: supposed to be Thirdis on this map

from bp.

Many thanks for your help, I will add these names to the mod. However, the Qasr ash-Shams you mentioned is a complete different place. I know about Babylon fortress and thought of using its name for Cairo, but later preferred Heliopolis (Coptic On).
In CK3 Qasr ash-Shams is located somewhere in Marmarica, in same county with Sallum.

from bp.

Many thanks for your help, I will add these names to the mod. However, the Qasr ash-Shams you mentioned is a complete different place. I know about Babylon fortress and thought of using its name for Cairo, but later preferred Heliopolis (Coptic On). In CK3 Qasr ash-Shams is located somewhere in Marmarica, in same county with Sallum.

Marsa Matrouh is the ancient Koinē Greek: Παραιτόνιον Paraitónion, Latin Paraetonium. It was the westernmost city of the Ptolemaic Kingdom in the Hellenistic period. The city of Apis, some 18 km to the west of Paraetonium, marked the boundary to Libycus nome, and the Halfaya Pass (at Sallum) marked the boundary to Marmarica proper.

Maybe something from this? "The city of Apis, 18 km to the west", e.g.

from bp.

Many thanks for your help, I will add these names to the mod. However, the Qasr ash-Shams you mentioned is a complete different place. I know about Babylon fortress and thought of using its name for Cairo, but later preferred Heliopolis (Coptic On). In CK3 Qasr ash-Shams is located somewhere in Marmarica, in same county with Sallum.

Marsa Matrouh is the ancient Koinē Greek: Παραιτόνιον Paraitónion, Latin Paraetonium. It was the westernmost city of the Ptolemaic Kingdom in the Hellenistic period. The city of Apis, some 18 km to the west of Paraetonium, marked the boundary to Libycus nome, and the Halfaya Pass (at Sallum) marked the boundary to Marmarica proper.

Maybe something from this? "The city of Apis, 18 km to the west", e.g.

Ok, I will add this as well.

from bp.

IMO for the Balkans a good solution would to add places from "De Aedificiis" by Procopius. There are a lot of toponyms and the vast majority of them still haven't been identified, but unfortunately many names are clearly corrupt.

from bp.

Jabal al-Gharbi should be Abbasca in stead of Wadi Masus, which in turn should be Herculis Tumuh;
Wadi Makhil is exactly Thirdis;
Jakharrad can be Migo;
(All of those 4 are from the earlier map with adjustment for me having the ck3 map also);
Ain al-Gharbi - there is literally nothing here except Sitra lake and road even nowadays;
Ibshaya - This (The city was home and headquarters of the first Pharaoh of a unified Egypt, Narmer. As of today, it is unconfirmed to whether this is the site of the ancient city of This (Thinis) or the nearby village of Birba which was the capital of Egypt during the 1st and 2nd dynasties);
Kanais al-Hadid - Zygris (https://pleiades.stoa.org/places/716656);
Abu Ghalib - Terenuthis (http://www.mappery.com/map-of/Ancient-Egypt-Map);
That's all for today's evening.

from bp.

@LT-Rascek isn't Paraetotium already presented? If not, then it's better, yes

from bp.

I'm seeing screenshots from old maps here, but @Symmachus are you using the the Digital Atlas of the Roman Empire? It is the most recent and complete initiative which gives tools to find places during the period. Old maps will rarely provide those references completely.

from bp.

I'm seeing screenshots from old maps here, but @Symmachus are you using the the Digital Atlas of the Roman Empire? It is the most recent and complete initiative which gives tools to find places during the period. Old maps will rarely provide those references completely.

I don't use the old maps - they were actually provided by @Freudensonne. Generally, I prefer to use Barrington Atlas of the Greek and Roman World as my main source. I believe its have more data than the Digital Atlas + there are also lists of unlocated toponyms that can be used as the names for unidentified locations. Since many Western European cities in CK3 were apparently founded only during the Middle Ages, I use Orbis Latinus as the source for their Latin names (although those are frequently written in Vulgar or Medieval Latin). Its especially useful for Gaul and Italy, since the vast majority of the local placenames are of Latin origin.

from bp.

I'm publishing the next list, this time for Roman Britain. This area so far is the hardest one, because the vast majority of the English toponyms are Germanic in origin + on their map of Britain PDX ommited many localities that existed during the Roman period. Because of these issues, I partially had to rely on pseudo names constructed by antiquarians centuries ago. Also, If there are no possible Roman settlements, plain etymological translation is also welcome. If you're into that, I can give you one tip from the antiquarians - they translated Anglo-Saxon tun/ton/town as Celtic "dunum". Anyway, here is the list:

*Tonbridge

*Tandbridge

*"Woxbrigge" (modern Uxbridge)

*Gore

*Dunmow

*Bedford

*Ampthill

*Luton

*Berkhamsted

*Kettering

*Walsingham

*Ipswich

*Sudbury

*Blything

*Radfield

*Papworth

*Yarlestre (a hundred in Anglo-Saxon England)

*Cottingham

*Sheffield

*Bolton

*Ripon

*Bolingsbroke

*Grimsby

*Bosworth

*Rutland

*Darlington

*Furness

*West Derby

*Appleby

*Macclesfield

*Chesterfield

*Coventry (the current name refers to neaby Lunt Roman fort, but that's a modern name)

*Birmingham

*Stafford

*Wolverhampton

*Evesham

*Kidderminster

*Ludlow

*Hereford

*Wigmore

*Winchcombe

*Banbury

*Witney

*Reading

*Basingstoke

*Carisbrooke

*Winterstoke (a hundred in Anglo-Saxon England)

from bp.

I'm publishing the next list, this time for Roman Britain. This area so far is the hardest one, because the vast majority of the English toponyms are Germanic in origin + on their map of Britain PDX ommited many localities that existed during the Roman period. Because of these issues, I partially had to rely on pseudo names constructed by antiquarians centuries ago. Also, If there are no possible Roman settlements, plain etymological translation is also welcome. If you're into that, I can give you one tip from the antiquarians - they translated Anglo-Saxon tun/ton/town as Celtic "dunum". Anyway, here is the list:

*Tonbridge

*Tandbridge

*"Woxbrigge" (modern Uxbridge)

*Gore

*Dunmow

*Bedford

*Ampthill

*Luton

*Berkhamsted

*Kettering

*Walsingham

*Ipswich

*Sudbury

*Blything

*Beodericsworth

*Radfield

*Papworth

*Yarlestre (a hundred in Anglo-Saxon England)

*Pockington

*Cottingham

*Sheffield

*Bolton

*Ripon

*Bolingsbroke

*Grimsby

*Melton

*Bosworth

*Rutland

*Rothbury

*Darlington

*Furness

*West Derby

*Appleby

*Macclesfield

*Chesterfield

*Coventry (the current name refers to neaby Lunt Roman fort, but that's a modern name)

*Birmingham

*Stafford

*Wolverhampton

*Evesham

*Kidderminster

*Shrewsbury

*Ludlow

*Hereford

*Wigmore

*Clifford

*Winchcombe

*Banbury

*Witney

*Reading

*Basingstoke

*Carisbrooke

*Winterstoke (a hundred in Anglo-Saxon England)

I feel like you should go and see what names Winter King mod for CK2 uses, they have very, very detailed provinces with dynamic names for baronies etc., so that map could be of help if set to Roman names (e.g. everything given to Roman character)

from bp.

I'm publishing the next list, this time for Roman Britain. This area so far is the hardest one, because the vast majority of the English toponyms are Germanic in origin + on their map of Britain PDX ommited many localities that existed during the Roman period. Because of these issues, I partially had to rely on pseudo names constructed by antiquarians centuries ago. Also, If there are no possible Roman settlements, plain etymological translation is also welcome. If you're into that, I can give you one tip from the antiquarians - they translated Anglo-Saxon tun/ton/town as Celtic "dunum". Anyway, here is the list:
*Tonbridge
*Tandbridge
*"Woxbrigge" (modern Uxbridge)
*Gore
*Dunmow
*Bedford
*Ampthill
*Luton
*Berkhamsted
*Kettering
*Walsingham
*Ipswich
*Sudbury
*Blything
*Beodericsworth
*Radfield
*Papworth
*Yarlestre (a hundred in Anglo-Saxon England)
*Pockington
*Cottingham
*Sheffield
*Bolton
*Ripon
*Bolingsbroke
*Grimsby
*Melton
*Bosworth
*Rutland
*Rothbury
*Darlington
*Furness
*West Derby
*Appleby
*Macclesfield
*Chesterfield
*Coventry (the current name refers to neaby Lunt Roman fort, but that's a modern name)
*Birmingham
*Stafford
*Wolverhampton
*Evesham
*Kidderminster
*Shrewsbury
*Ludlow
*Hereford
*Wigmore
*Clifford
*Winchcombe
*Banbury
*Witney
*Reading
*Basingstoke
*Carisbrooke
*Winterstoke (a hundred in Anglo-Saxon England)

I feel like you should go and see what names Winter King mod for CK2 uses, they have very, very detailed provinces with dynamic names for baronies etc., so that map could be of help if set to Roman names (e.g. everything given to Roman character)

That could be done but it requires asking permission beforehand, we need to get that from then before we can use their research.

from bp.

I feel like you should go and see what names Winter King mod for CK2 uses, they have very, very detailed provinces with dynamic names for baronies etc., so that map could be of help if set to Roman names (e.g. everything given to Roman character)

I know about TBWK and have already researched its map. I used the TBWK data only if there was 100% match between the Roman settlement and its Anglo-Saxon successor (or at least if the distance was very short, like one or two kms). I'm saying that because much of the stuff they added was pretty inaccurate. For example, Ipswich in TBWK is called "Combretovium" under the Romans, but in fact this city was 12.8 km from it, which is quite a distance.

from bp.

Next list - the North Africa. Unlike the previous two ones, I actually finished doing this part of the map, adding everything I could find. The most problematic part is Mauretania Tingitana, because there are very few named Roman-era settlements.

It is worth to note a large number of titular Catholic sees in Africa Proconsularis, Byzacena, Numidia and Mauretania Caesariensis, the exact location of which had been lost to history. These cities can be used as gap-fillers if needed.
Here is the list:

• Tahlit (Idrisid mint court mentioned in Hesperis Tamuda, where its described as located "s/ Oued Loukkos, en aval d'el-Ksar el Kebir")

• Ghumira

• Nakur

• Fes

• Wargha

• Warzigh

• Al-Aliya

• Subu

• Missour

• Tikoutamine

• El-Ksabi

• Taza

• Nador

• Meknes

• Baht

• Segrou

• Tagragra

• Izerhan (Idrisid mint court mentioned in Hesperis Tamuda, where its described as located "s/ oued Jerhane, affl. de rive g. du Sebou, près du confl. 21 km N.-E. Sidi-Kassem")

• Watit (Idrisid mint court mentioned in Hesperis Tamuda, where its described as located "au jbel Outita, 8 km S.-O. Sidi-Kassem")

• Ribat al Fath (modern Rabat)

• Muaskar

• Ain Tekbalet (Barrington Atlas notes Roman-era settlement-marble quarry there, but doesn't list its ancient name)

• Tafraou

• Saa

• Debdou

• Qalaa Bhuwara

• Al-Gabal

• Ikjan

• Qalaa Bhammad (Qalaa beni Hammad)

• Raqqada

• Mansuriya

• Al-Abbasiya

• Izan

• Maskiana (Meskiana) (Barrington Atlas notes Roman-era settlement there, but doesn't list its ancient name)

• Hamma

• Sidi Ukba (Sidi Okba)

• Waghlanat (Ourlel)

• Tamazda

• Tiri

• Souf

• Douz

• Tajrift

• Tinnai

from bp.

Gaul (in fact, all of these have medieval Latin names, but etymologies are Germanic):

• Malboden (Maubeuge)

• Forbach

• Vaudémont

• Bitsch (Bitche)

• Püttlingen (Puttelange-aux-Lacs)

• Finstingen (Fénétrange)

• Wadern

• Adenau

• Sponheim

• Porrentruy

• Mulhouse

• Ornans

• Château-Renard

• Hayange

• Montlhéry

• Harcourt

• Dieppe

• La Haye (Descartes)

• Châtellerault

Upd: Per Loup's request I removed the cities that are located in Germanized areas in northern and eastern parts of the country.

from bp.

For cities that were originally Frankish settlement the Early Medieval Latin equivalents make sense, there is simply no Roman counterpart. However when there is an alternative Roman settlement in territories under Sub-Roman control that name should be preferred over the Frankish/Germanic one. I believe that makes for a reasonable compromise.

from bp.

Hispania:

• Almaraz

• Calatrava

• Huelamo

• Maqueda

• Coracera

• Medina del Pomar

• San Leonardo de Yagüe

• Alpuente

• Calaceite

• Monte Faro

from bp.

Italy (mostly Noricum, really):

• Obalj

• Visoki

• Bobovac

• Kučlat

• Srebrenik

• Maglaj

• Krapina

• Krupa

• Glaž

• Egerszeg (Zalaegerszeg)

• Csurgó

• Letenye

• Kapuvár

• Szentgotthárd

• Werdenberg

• Sankt Gallen (Latin, but very anachronistic - named after Saint Gall (550-646) who settled there in 612)

• Ravensburg

• Peiting

• Hohenschwangau

• Friedberg

• Wolfsrathausen

• Eschenlohe

• Tölz

• Leonsberg

• Frontenhausen

• Dornberg

• Ortenburg

• Geisenhausen

• Rothenburg

• Freising

• Münchsmünster

• Ilmmünster

• Aheim

• Graz

• Köflach

• Feldbach

• Pitten

• Oberwart

• Mürzzuschlag

• Marburg (Maribor)

• Lutenburg

• Irdning

• Knittelfeld

• Admont

• Leukental

• Hallstatt

• Straßwalchen

• Ried

• Scharding

• Waidhofen

from bp.