This proposal contains a detailed specification of Option 5 to allow top-level markings that are easy to use as well as field-level markings. (Use Case).

The scope of this specification is only in defining what markings apply to, not to the definition of the markings themselves. Assume the following preconditions:

• One or more marking models are defined (e.g. TLP, copyright, terms of use)
• STIX 2.0 top-level objects may not be embedded in other top-level objects
• STIX 2.0 top-level objects are to be determined, but minimally include all STIX 1.2 top-level objects (pending changes)

This approach maintains the current (STIX 1.2) pattern for applying field-level markings but adds an additional capability to support more basic markings.

• Level 1 Markings: Level 1 markings allow markings to be applied at two levels: the package as a whole, and top-level objects.
• Level 2 Markings: Level 2 markings allow markings to be applied at any level, down to individual fields.

Level 1 markings and Level 2 markings are mechanisms for applying markings, not defining them. Markings are always defined via the same approach (see: Marking Definitions) regardless of whether they're applied as Level 1 markings, Level 2 markings, or both.

Data markings are defined in the marking_definitions field of a STIX package. The field is a list (array) of 1 or more marking definitions. Each definition contains two relevant fields:

• the id field is a standard STIX globally-unique ID
• the marking_type field identifies which type of data marking is being defined (e.g. TLP)

Additional fields on the marking definition contain data for the marking itself (e.g., for TLP marking definitions there would be a field for color)

Markings definitions may be referenced either within the document or externally.

Level 1 markings allow producers to mark entire packages and top-level objects via a simple and straightforward approach.

Level 1 markings are contained in the marking_refs field, which is a list (array) of marking references (IDs of marking definitions). When used at the package level, the markings referenced in the list apply to the package itself and to each of the top-level objects in the package. When used on a top-level object, the markings apply to that object.

Markings applied at the object level override all markings of the same type that were applied at the package level. In other words, if the marking type in the object-level marking_refs matches a type that was applied at the package-level, the markings at the package level do not apply to that object.

Level 2 markings allow producers to marking individual fields with marking statements via an approach similar to the existing STIX 1.2 specification (leveraging a controlled structure).

Level 2 markings are contained in the structured_markings field, which is an array of objects that may be used either at the STIX package level or on any top-level object. Each object in the array consists of two fields:

• controlled_structure: contains a list of controlled structures, each of which is a representation of the fields that the referenced marking are applied to. In the JSON MTI specification, the format of each item is a string JSONPath entry.
• marking_refs: contains a list of references to the marking definitions to be applied, identical to Level 1 markings.

When used on a package, the root of the controlled_structure expression is the package. When used on a top-level object, the root of the controlled_structure expression is the object.

Level 2 markings override all Level 1 markings of the same type. Level 2 markings applied at the object override Level 2 markings of the same type applied at the package, and markings that appear later in a list override those of the same type appearing earlier in the list.

A Level 0 Markings Processor is not able to process data markings. A Level 1 Markings Processor is only able to process Level 1 data markings. A Level 2 Markings Processor is able to process both Level 1 markings and Level 2 markings.

• 0.1: A Level 0 processor who receives a document that contains either Level 1 or Level 2 markings at the package level MUST reject the document.
• 0.2: A Level 0 processor who receives a document that DOES NOT contain Level 1 or Level 2 markings at the package level MAY accept the document.
• 0.3: A Level 0 processor processing a document that contains an object with Level 1 or Level 2 markings MUST reject the object. It MAY continue to process the rest of the document.

• 1.1: A Level 1 processor who receives a package that contains Level 2 markings at the package level MUST reject the document.
• 1.2: A Level 1 processor who receives a document that DOES NOT contain Level 2 markings at the package level MAY accept the document.
• 1.3: A Level 1 processor processing a document that contains an object with Level 2 markings MUST reject the object. It MAY continue to process the rest of the document.
• 1.4: A Level 1 processor MUST process all Level 1 markings per the mechanisms outlined in this specification.

• 2.1: A Level 2 processor MUST process all Level 1 and Level 2 markings per the mechanisms outlined in this specification.

• 3.1: Level 1 and Level 2 processors MUST honor the following order of precedence when encountering more than one marking application with the same type:
  • Level 2 markings at the object level, in reverse order of occurrence (e.g. later markings override earlier markings of the same type)
  • Level 2 markings at the package level, in reverse order of occurrence (e.g. later markings override earlier markings of the same type)
  • Level 1 markings at the object level
  • Level 1 markings at the package level

• 4.1: Level 1 and Level 2 processors that are unable to resolve a reference to a marking definition MUST reject content marked by that definition.

In this example, two marking definitions are represented. They are not applied anywhere via either Level 1 or Level 2 markings.

{
  "stix_version": "2.0",
  "marking_definitions": [
    {
      "id": "us-cert:TLP-GREEN",
      "marking_type": "tlp",
      "tlp": "GREEN"
    },
    {
      "id": "example.com:copyright-1234",
      "marking_type": "simple",
      "statement": "Copyright 2015, Example Inc."
    }
  ]
}

In this example, the entire document is marked TLP:GREEN.

{
  "stix_version": "2.0",
  "marking_definitions": [
    {
      "id": "us-cert:TLP-GREEN",
      "marking_type": "tlp",
      "tlp": "GREEN"
    }
  ],
  "marking_refs": ["us-cert:TLP-GREEN"],
  "indicators": [
    {},
    {},
    {}
  ]
}

In this example, the first indicator is marked TLP:RED and the second is marked TLP:GREEN.

{
  "stix_version": "2.0",
  "marking_definitions": [
    {
      "id": "us-cert:TLP-GREEN",
      "marking_type": "tlp",
      "tlp": "GREEN"
    },
    {
      "id": "us-cert:TLP-RED",
      "marking_type": "tlp",
      "tlp": "RED"
    }
  ],
  "indicators": [
    {
      "id": "indicator-1234",
      "marking_refs": ["us-cert:TLP-RED"],
      "title": "First indicator"
    },
    {
      "id": "indicator-4321",
      "marking_refs": ["us-cert:TLP-GREEN"],
      "title": "Second indicator"
    }
  ]
}

In this example, the package is marked TLP:GREEN but a single indicator in that package is marked TLP:RED. In this case, the package itself and the second indicator are considered GREEN but the first indicator is considered RED because a Level 1 marking of type=tlp at the object level overrides the same type applied at the package level.

{
  "stix_version": "2.0",
  "marking_definitions": [
    {
      "id": "us-cert:TLP-GREEN",
      "marking_type": "tlp",
      "tlp": "GREEN"
    },
    {
      "id": "us-cert:TLP-RED",
      "marking_type": "tlp",
      "tlp": "RED"
    },

  ],
  "marking_refs": ["us-cert:TLP-GREEN"],
  "indicators": [
    {
      "id": "indicator-1234",
      "marking_refs": ["us-cert:TLP-RED"],
      "title": "First indicator"
    },
    {
      "id": "indicator-4321",
      "title": "Second indicator"
    }
  ]
}

In this example, the title field of the indicator is marked as TLP:RED. A Level 1 processor would accept the package but reject the indicator because it contains a Level 2 indicator.

{
  "stix_version": "2.0",
  "marking_definitions": [
    {
      "id": "us-cert:TLP-RED",
      "marking_type": "tlp",
      "tlp": "RED"
    }
  ],
  "indicators": [
    {
      "id": "indicator-1234",
      "structured_markings": [
        {
          "controlled_structure": [
            "@.title"
          ],
          "marking_refs": ["us-cert:TLP-RED"]
        }
      ],
      "title": "First indicator"
    }
  ]
}

Here, the entire document is marked TLP:GREEN and later an indicator title is marked TLP:RED. Note that in this example, a Level 1 processor would be able to process the package and the second indicator but MUST reject the first indicator because it contains Level 2 markings.

{
  "stix_version": "2.0",
  "marking_definitions": [
    {
      "id": "us-cert:TLP-RED",
      "marking_type": "tlp",
      "tlp": "RED"
    },
    {
      "id": "us-cert:TLP-GREEN",
      "marking_type": "tlp",
      "tlp": "GREEN"
    }
  ],
  "marking_refs": ["us-cert:TLP-GREEN"],
  "indicators": [
    {
      "id": "indicator-1234",
      "structured_markings": [
        {
          "controlled_structure": [
            "@.title"
          ],
          "marking_refs": ["us-cert:TLP-RED"]
        }
      ],
      "title": "First indicator"
    },
    {
      "id": "indicator-4321",
      "title": "Second indicator"
    }
  ]
}