General

• Click to enable pan / zoom -> Enable / Disable
• Trucks in first graphic don't show up on safari @haldenl
• Preload videos / images for media visualization @haldenl
• Add urls to all graphic sources @haldenl
• Add parametric preview @haldenl
• Animate first graphic? @haldenl
• Make deep passes over preview. Make sure text is good and everything is cited. @haldenl @lilianliang @anirmal1 @ssshathi
• Add company logo in conclusion text (permission issues here... quite strict on branding usage) @haldenl
• Move rewrite of last paragraph to preview (with sources) @ssshathi
• Some periods dont have spaces after them @ssshathi
• Better punchy description? (see slack discussion w/ Fred)
• Add subhed to pipeline components @haldenl
• Record page for media emissions @haldenl @ssshathi
• Media picker autoplay gets interrupted by hover. @haldenl
• Switch modes -> Show Timeline / Hide Timeline @haldenl
• Cite google peering website for google cache storing more popular videos. @haldenl
• Car distance equivalent should read "Loading Facebook is equivalent ..." @haldenl
• Cite priest et al after each electricity info. @ssshathi
• Move last paragraph of pipeline to scroller (with no graphic?) To test how it looks @haldenl
• Remove periods in superfund map status @lilianliang
• Move google aside in conclusion (check location on mobile). @anirmal1
• Pipeline graphic shows grab / grabbing cursor.
• Add sources/ titles to all graphics.
• Add reference point for media picker emissions
• Devices take into account lifecycle in Belkhir and Elmeligi but not in Priest et al?
• Add sources for pipeline vis
• Add caption / axis labels to pipeline line chart
• Match text to reflect cropped pipeline graphic (reduced # of datacenters)
• Can't hover over points in superfund map when zoom / drag is disabled.
• Fix globe is cropped sometimes (add resize listener)
• Fix flicker on Safari for superfund map. (looks like a beta only bug)
• Crop pipeline graphic to exclude las vegas (there is a data center there)
• Fix tooltip text colors or background in superfund map.
• Window resize is slow.
• Trucks are backwards
• Make media picker interaction on hover for desktop
• Pipeline text does not match graphic after removal of a step.
• Video emissions title should read 'Emissions of Video'

Mobile

• Videos not autoplaying in safari ios
• Try to move media emission parts further down in the section @anirmal1
• Change text that refers to visualizations (position) for media emissions section. @anirmal1
• Remove long touch action for media picker
• Media picker hold not working
• Media picker timeline touch drag not working
• Pipeline graphic overflows the viewport at stages?
• Superfund map randomly resizes when scrolling?
• Media emissions caption should change to tap & hold for touchscreens.
• Support globe rotate (this would cause scroll jacking)
• Fix superfund map zoom
• Fix end of pipeline layout / text overlap (the view with the comparison between youtube and ict sector emissions)
• Fix incorrect y translate for youtube graphic (causing "ICT Sector (2010)" text to appear during entire pipeline)
• Fix scroll jacking on superfund map

Issues

• Rerun data (last item: once rest of changes are in)
• Add instructions for running code in readme @ssshathi
• Fix sources for fb, goog, amzn, apple pledges for carbon free @mathisonian
• Check if deckgl has fixed flicker bug for safari in Big Sur
• (#22) Bolded text -> white? @anirmal1 @haldenl
• (#23) Copyright issues for album art?
• Don't use caption for footnote? @anirmal1
• Remove margin from scrolly (above and below).
• Double check code for data collection @haldenl @ssshathi
• Verify that songs fetch only the audio @ssshathi
• Get photo for fairchild factory? cant find one with license
• (#21) Style graphic sources for mobile
• (#20) Switch media picker preview to click instead of click + hold
• Rewrite pledge paragraph
• Typos (see slack thread
• CO2 -> CO_2
• Pipeline emissions bar doesn't match up for cdns.
• IMPORTANT: Fix video preloading (loading videos multiple times rn).

Dragan's Feedback

• (#11) Podcast vs Old Town Road = misleading. @anirmal1 @lilianliang
• (#11) Video streaming similarly misleading. @anirmal1 @lilianliang
• (#13) Is meter driven by car meaningful? @haldenl

Jane's Feedback

• 'timeline breakdown of each title' -> title not the right word ('artifact' or 'type of media') instead? @anirmal1
• More space between name / bios for authors & end of article. @haldenl
• (#19) 'Case Study' -> Nice to talk a bit more about where this case study came from. @ssshathi
• I think it would help to have more context / explanation around the first Priest et al. estimate. For example: "Priest et al. estimate that the energy to run all of Google's data centers account for less than 2% of Youtube's total electricity use." @ssshathi
• "But their burden is still being felt today" -> burden to something else? @ssshathi
• (#12) Consider splitting last text bubble of pipeline into multiple with clearer points (slack thread has examples). @lilianliang
• (#12) "YouTube's monthly active user count has since... [so the CO2 emissions are even higher...]" @lilianliang
• (#14) Emissions of audio should have audio?
• (#15) Have 360p + 1080p preview? Or make clear its just one
• (#16) 'Sparkline' in Emissions of Video section to remind reader of emissions from earlier sections that are referenced.
• (#17) Labeling may clarify the meaning of 4 lines in projection.
• (#18) Can "YouTube (2016)" header fade in above corresponding bar? Instead of below.
• "Belkhir and Elmeligi created two models to project the ICT sector's [emissions] decades forward"
• "[enough to power] over half a million U.S. homes"
• Any way to less blur the facebook preview? Privacy, so no.
• Pipeline map state borders are faint.. IMO this is fine.
• Media Emissions by Medium -> x axis labels at top too? (too tall).. I've removed the car equivalent text to make the vis a little shorter. Otherwise, I don't think putting the x axis labels on top provides too much value. The emissions of each bar are already labeled.

Other feedback

• Review

Smaller Issues

• "Components & Electricity Usage" -> Shorter title? (creates 2 lines on mobile).
• (#23) Need to link websites / videos / audio?
• Superfund map randomly resizes when scrolling? @haldenl
• [Mobile] Globe freezes when touched. @haldenl
• Scroller has awkward space steps between on mobile.
• Album art preview placement covers title.
• Address caching for websites? Specify we used chrome?
• [Mobile] Pipeline graphic overflows the viewport at stages? @haldenl

The Mapbox map at the end of the article does not show data when viewing in Safari.

In Safari, the maps in the sidebar are much smaller than in Chrome. Could be s Safari CSS issue.