whym / commons-app-stats Goto Github PK

Hi @whym , the quarterly histogram appears to be broken. CSV file has lots of "NoName"s and "NoTitle"s too.

Sorry to bother but it's the stats time of the year again. :)

Not that there is any problem with how things are right now, but have you considered trasnferring this project to the organization at https://github.com/commons-app?
It would be more visible to developers who roam around the Commons app looking for things to improve :-)
Of course if you prefer to keep it, it is perfectly fine.
Cheers!

Hi @whym ,

I just glanced at this chart today and it seems that the weekly stats have stalled? The last bar was from 18 Feb 2018. Is it normal to have a month's lag time, or is something wrong with the stats?

Also, does this affect the quarterly count at 2018 Q1?

Thanks!

Hi @whym ,

The new quarterly histogram seems to be a bit buggy - edits aren't shown in 2017, and uploads in 2017 Q2 appears lower than I recall. Is there a reason why we switched to the new quarterly histogram? I admit to being partial to the old one which displayed data from the start of the app (in 2013 or something I think), as that gave a very good overall picture of stats. :)

I noticed that there was a marked drop in uploads for the past ~5 wks (from ~500/wk to <100/wk). Do you know if there might be an error in the data collection @whym ? If not (and therefore the drop is accurate), I will need to take a look at why the uploads have dropped so much.

Thanks!

Hi @whym ,

I've been following these stats with interest and was wondering if there was a way of viewing the exact numbers that make up the histograms? (e.g. 2016 Q4 might have 4239 new uploads, 2 overwrites, 467 deletes, etc). I glanced at the raw csv data but that only seems to have the unaggregated data.

The reason I'm asking is that I was planning to use the stats aggregated by your tool to report on the measures of success for my IEG when it ends next month, if at all possible.

Thanks!

Both the chart and CSV seem to stop on March 20, 2023:

https://commons-app-stats.toolforge.org/latest_quarter.csv.gz

Maybe the tool stopped running?

It seems like the standard solution for specifying colors is

This was a byproduct of solving #5 by updating libraries.

Hi @whym ,

It seems like the quarterly histogram is broken again?

Sorry for the trouble, haha. :)

Minor issue, but red is typically associated with "bad", aka deletions IMO. Strange to see edits in red and deletions in green. :)

We need to exclude Suggested Edits edits from the stats. Wikipedia app now allows users to edit Wikimedia Commons (https://www.mediawiki.org/wiki/Wikimedia_Apps/Suggested_edits#Image_captions). Example: https://commons.wikimedia.org/w/index.php?title=File:Yukyuzan_Kouen_2019,05.jpg&diff=prev&oldid=388969580 . Those edits seem to be tagged with "mobile app edit" and "Suggested Edits edit" tags, while edits via Commons app have the former only - which I think can be used to separate the two.

Split from #14 (comment)

Hi @whym , I think the quarterly stats might be broken - they only display lots of thin lines to me (instead of the histogram).

Hi @whym , the last week of stats that I can see is from 5th August. Any idea what the issue is? :)

Thanks!

Hi @whym , the data collection appears to be broken - not just the histogram, but even the .csv file shows 'NoName' and 'NoTitle' for everything.

Sorry to bother you, but I am trying to start collecting stats for our final report, and 2 of our metrics of success rely on the data obtained from this repo. :)

Thanks so much!

Context: I'm trying to make the stats tool more informative, and as a preparation, I'm creating a few datasets and graphs. Some of these may get into the next iteration of the stats tool if the information seems useful.

Question: We know the number of active installs is around 3400 (as of March 2018, probably a bit more than that now). How many of them are using the app as a primary tool to contribute to Commons?

Results: For this I made https://quarry.wmflabs.org/query/27068 (​​https://quarry.wmflabs.org/run/262407/output/0/json?download=true) to retrieve the list of all Commons contributors who made at least one upload. If I use a (admittedly arbitrary) threshold of mobile_app_uploads / editcount = 0.6, it seems to show that there are 1000-ish app-only Commons contributors vs 3000-ish of the app's users.

What's next:

• It's just a quickly made query and I'm not sure if I'm getting this number correct actually - is this consistent with the number of app installs? Anything I'm missing?
• Since we now have a list of mobile-only users, how is the segment of users different from other segments, in terms of style, quality, geography, etc?

Dataset

@whym Seems like the last week recorded at https://tools.wmflabs.org/commons-app-stats/ is 16 Sep?