Thanks for your code. I have some questions about your experiments
#########################
In train.py:
optimizer = optim.SGD([
{'params': net.classifier_concat.parameters(), 'lr': 0.002},
{'params': net.conv_block1.parameters(), 'lr': 0.002},
{'params': net.classifier1.parameters(), 'lr': 0.002},
{'params': net.conv_block2.parameters(), 'lr': 0.002},
{'params': net.classifier2.parameters(), 'lr': 0.002},
{'params': net.conv_block3.parameters(), 'lr': 0.002},
{'params': net.classifier3.parameters(), 'lr': 0.002},
# {'params': net.features.parameters(), 'lr': 0.0002}
],
momentum=0.9, weight_decay=5e-4)
if I do not commented out {'params': net.features.parameters(), 'lr': 0.0002}, loss has always been 5.3, unable to drop.
if I commented it, I can not obtain your accuracy in your paper. it only 88.17742
#################################################################
True
==> Preparing data..
/home/wjz/anaconda3/lib/python3.7/site-packages/torchvision/transforms/transforms.py:208: UserWarning: The use of the transforms.Scale transform is deprecated, please use transforms.Resize instead.
warnings.warn("The use of the transforms.Scale transform is deprecated, " +
==> Building model..
Epoch: 0
Step: 0 | Loss1: 5.377 | Loss2: 5.23951 | Loss3: 5.25872 | Loss_concat: 10.77344 | Loss: 26.648 | Acc: 0.000% (0/16)
Step: 100 | Loss1: 5.210 | Loss2: 5.24563 | Loss3: 5.01386 | Loss_concat: 9.87350 | Loss: 25.343 | Acc: 5.384% (87/1616)
Step: 200 | Loss1: 5.092 | Loss2: 5.11479 | Loss3: 4.72915 | Loss_concat: 9.01229 | Loss: 23.948 | Acc: 12.687% (408/3216)
Step: 300 | Loss1: 4.982 | Loss2: 4.95620 | Loss3: 4.48933 | Loss_concat: 8.25784 | Loss: 22.685 | Acc: 19.788% (953/4816)
/home/wjz/code-lee/PMG-Progressive-Multi-Granularity-Training-master/utils.py:89: UserWarning: volatile was removed and now has no effect. Use with torch.no_grad():
instead.
inputs, targets = Variable(inputs, volatile=True), Variable(targets)
Step: 1931 | Loss: 2.399 | Acc: 54.815% (3176/5794) |Combined Acc: 50.932% (2951/5794)
best acc is = 50.93200
Epoch: 1
Step: 0 | Loss1: 4.278 | Loss2: 3.97236 | Loss3: 3.05924 | Loss_concat: 4.15896 | Loss: 15.468 | Acc: 68.750% (11/16)
Step: 100 | Loss1: 4.303 | Loss2: 3.97899 | Loss3: 3.27661 | Loss_concat: 4.43286 | Loss: 15.992 | Acc: 62.933% (1017/1616)
Step: 200 | Loss1: 4.248 | Loss2: 3.86615 | Loss3: 3.17743 | Loss_concat: 4.16216 | Loss: 15.454 | Acc: 64.272% (2067/3216)
Step: 300 | Loss1: 4.163 | Loss2: 3.73736 | Loss3: 3.05000 | Loss_concat: 3.86442 | Loss: 14.815 | Acc: 66.549% (3205/4816)
Step: 1931 | Loss: 1.305 | Acc: 72.541% (4203/5794) |Combined Acc: 70.849% (4105/5794)
best acc is = 70.84915
Epoch: 2
Step: 0 | Loss1: 4.154 | Loss2: 3.51961 | Loss3: 2.77444 | Loss_concat: 2.85724 | Loss: 13.305 | Acc: 81.250% (13/16)
Step: 100 | Loss1: 3.637 | Loss2: 2.99386 | Loss3: 2.37375 | Loss_concat: 2.24752 | Loss: 11.252 | Acc: 81.869% (1323/1616)
Step: 200 | Loss1: 3.597 | Loss2: 2.90487 | Loss3: 2.29093 | Loss_concat: 2.14175 | Loss: 10.935 | Acc: 82.027% (2638/3216)
Step: 300 | Loss1: 3.556 | Loss2: 2.83164 | Loss3: 2.22867 | Loss_concat: 2.09540 | Loss: 10.712 | Acc: 81.561% (3928/4816)
Step: 1931 | Loss: 0.941 | Acc: 78.719% (4561/5794) |Combined Acc: 77.977% (4518/5794)
best acc is = 77.97722
Epoch: 3
Step: 0 | Loss1: 3.134 | Loss2: 2.36535 | Loss3: 1.68741 | Loss_concat: 1.25920 | Loss: 8.446 | Acc: 87.500% (14/16)
Step: 100 | Loss1: 3.093 | Loss2: 2.23144 | Loss3: 1.74485 | Loss_concat: 1.31555 | Loss: 8.385 | Acc: 89.975% (1454/1616)
Step: 200 | Loss1: 3.063 | Loss2: 2.18541 | Loss3: 1.72284 | Loss_concat: 1.31887 | Loss: 8.290 | Acc: 88.806% (2856/3216)
Step: 300 | Loss1: 3.015 | Loss2: 2.13142 | Loss3: 1.69159 | Loss_concat: 1.31001 | Loss: 8.148 | Acc: 88.538% (4264/4816)
Step: 1931 | Loss: 0.830 | Acc: 80.238% (4649/5794) |Combined Acc: 80.014% (4636/5794)
best acc is = 80.01381
Epoch: 4
Step: 0 | Loss1: 2.775 | Loss2: 1.91765 | Loss3: 1.20096 | Loss_concat: 0.71040 | Loss: 6.604 | Acc: 100.000% (16/16)
Step: 100 | Loss1: 2.620 | Loss2: 1.68805 | Loss3: 1.32646 | Loss_concat: 0.83745 | Loss: 6.472 | Acc: 93.255% (1507/1616)
Step: 200 | Loss1: 2.601 | Loss2: 1.68000 | Loss3: 1.36257 | Loss_concat: 0.88198 | Loss: 6.525 | Acc: 92.382% (2971/3216)
Step: 300 | Loss1: 2.585 | Loss2: 1.66417 | Loss3: 1.35662 | Loss_concat: 0.88429 | Loss: 6.490 | Acc: 92.587% (4459/4816)
Step: 1931 | Loss: 0.772 | Acc: 80.980% (4692/5794) |Combined Acc: 82.361% (4772/5794)
best acc is = 82.36106
Epoch: 5
Step: 0 | Loss1: 2.307 | Loss2: 1.32481 | Loss3: 1.04585 | Loss_concat: 0.54067 | Loss: 5.219 | Acc: 93.750% (15/16)
Step: 100 | Loss1: 2.272 | Loss2: 1.38220 | Loss3: 1.13268 | Loss_concat: 0.57141 | Loss: 5.358 | Acc: 96.782% (1564/1616)
Step: 200 | Loss1: 2.240 | Loss2: 1.36626 | Loss3: 1.13537 | Loss_concat: 0.58879 | Loss: 5.331 | Acc: 95.771% (3080/3216)
Step: 300 | Loss1: 2.196 | Loss2: 1.33614 | Loss3: 1.10822 | Loss_concat: 0.58265 | Loss: 5.223 | Acc: 95.909% (4619/4816)
Step: 1931 | Loss: 0.710 | Acc: 82.741% (4794/5794) |Combined Acc: 83.155% (4818/5794)
best acc is = 83.15499
Epoch: 6
Step: 0 | Loss1: 1.868 | Loss2: 1.36466 | Loss3: 1.12972 | Loss_concat: 0.45856 | Loss: 4.821 | Acc: 100.000% (16/16)
Step: 100 | Loss1: 1.914 | Loss2: 1.08908 | Loss3: 0.92351 | Loss_concat: 0.38538 | Loss: 4.312 | Acc: 98.391% (1590/1616)
Step: 200 | Loss1: 1.866 | Loss2: 1.08991 | Loss3: 0.93069 | Loss_concat: 0.39588 | Loss: 4.283 | Acc: 98.290% (3161/3216)
Step: 300 | Loss1: 1.858 | Loss2: 1.07807 | Loss3: 0.93373 | Loss_concat: 0.40798 | Loss: 4.278 | Acc: 98.131% (4726/4816)
Step: 1931 | Loss: 0.673 | Acc: 83.051% (4812/5794) |Combined Acc: 84.225% (4880/5794)
best acc is = 84.22506
Epoch: 7
Step: 0 | Loss1: 1.646 | Loss2: 0.73913 | Loss3: 0.72481 | Loss_concat: 0.13935 | Loss: 3.249 | Acc: 100.000% (16/16)
Step: 100 | Loss1: 1.667 | Loss2: 0.96090 | Loss3: 0.82415 | Loss_concat: 0.29849 | Loss: 3.751 | Acc: 98.886% (1598/1616)
Step: 200 | Loss1: 1.647 | Loss2: 0.94296 | Loss3: 0.82795 | Loss_concat: 0.30366 | Loss: 3.721 | Acc: 98.974% (3183/3216)
Step: 300 | Loss1: 1.647 | Loss2: 0.93813 | Loss3: 0.82634 | Loss_concat: 0.31724 | Loss: 3.728 | Acc: 98.816% (4759/4816)
Step: 1931 | Loss: 0.686 | Acc: 82.775% (4796/5794) |Combined Acc: 84.605% (4902/5794)
best acc is = 84.60476
Epoch: 8
Step: 0 | Loss1: 1.551 | Loss2: 0.71522 | Loss3: 0.66501 | Loss_concat: 0.37301 | Loss: 3.304 | Acc: 93.750% (15/16)
Step: 100 | Loss1: 1.434 | Loss2: 0.82763 | Loss3: 0.73410 | Loss_concat: 0.23517 | Loss: 3.231 | Acc: 99.134% (1602/1616)
Step: 200 | Loss1: 1.449 | Loss2: 0.82253 | Loss3: 0.75179 | Loss_concat: 0.23583 | Loss: 3.259 | Acc: 99.223% (3191/3216)
Step: 300 | Loss1: 1.455 | Loss2: 0.82359 | Loss3: 0.75617 | Loss_concat: 0.24143 | Loss: 3.276 | Acc: 99.232% (4779/4816)
Step: 1931 | Loss: 0.641 | Acc: 83.621% (4845/5794) |Combined Acc: 85.261% (4940/5794)
best acc is = 85.26061
Epoch: 9
Step: 0 | Loss1: 1.078 | Loss2: 0.53219 | Loss3: 0.55669 | Loss_concat: 0.15284 | Loss: 2.319 | Acc: 100.000% (16/16)
Step: 100 | Loss1: 1.267 | Loss2: 0.68631 | Loss3: 0.62334 | Loss_concat: 0.16206 | Loss: 2.739 | Acc: 99.505% (1608/1616)
Step: 200 | Loss1: 1.259 | Loss2: 0.68253 | Loss3: 0.63172 | Loss_concat: 0.17208 | Loss: 2.745 | Acc: 99.440% (3198/3216)
Step: 300 | Loss1: 1.269 | Loss2: 0.69679 | Loss3: 0.64298 | Loss_concat: 0.17706 | Loss: 2.786 | Acc: 99.522% (4793/4816)
Step: 1931 | Loss: 0.654 | Acc: 83.707% (4850/5794) |Combined Acc: 84.484% (4895/5794)
best acc is = 85.26061
Epoch: 10
Step: 0 | Loss1: 0.786 | Loss2: 0.55738 | Loss3: 0.49358 | Loss_concat: 0.12876 | Loss: 1.966 | Acc: 100.000% (16/16)
Step: 100 | Loss1: 1.149 | Loss2: 0.64301 | Loss3: 0.59554 | Loss_concat: 0.15040 | Loss: 2.538 | Acc: 99.691% (1611/1616)
Step: 200 | Loss1: 1.144 | Loss2: 0.63301 | Loss3: 0.59002 | Loss_concat: 0.15469 | Loss: 2.522 | Acc: 99.720% (3207/3216)
Step: 300 | Loss1: 1.146 | Loss2: 0.63196 | Loss3: 0.59039 | Loss_concat: 0.15597 | Loss: 2.524 | Acc: 99.751% (4804/4816)
Step: 1931 | Loss: 0.625 | Acc: 84.225% (4880/5794) |Combined Acc: 85.727% (4967/5794)
best acc is = 85.72661
........................
Epoch: 198
Step: 0 | Loss1: 0.088 | Loss2: 0.05407 | Loss3: 0.09423 | Loss_concat: 0.05326 | Loss: 0.289 | Acc: 100.000% (16/16)
Step: 100 | Loss1: 0.060 | Loss2: 0.05452 | Loss3: 0.05455 | Loss_concat: 0.04034 | Loss: 0.209 | Acc: 100.000% (1616/1616)
Step: 200 | Loss1: 0.060 | Loss2: 0.05510 | Loss3: 0.05459 | Loss_concat: 0.04000 | Loss: 0.210 | Acc: 100.000% (3216/3216)
Step: 300 | Loss1: 0.059 | Loss2: 0.05373 | Loss3: 0.05290 | Loss_concat: 0.03933 | Loss: 0.205 | Acc: 100.000% (4816/4816)
Step: 1931 | Loss: 0.707 | Acc: 87.677% (5080/5794) |Combined Acc: 88.091% (5104/5794)
best acc is = 88.17742
Epoch: 199
Step: 0 | Loss1: 0.056 | Loss2: 0.04339 | Loss3: 0.04779 | Loss_concat: 0.03247 | Loss: 0.180 | Acc: 100.000% (16/16)
Step: 100 | Loss1: 0.059 | Loss2: 0.05347 | Loss3: 0.05479 | Loss_concat: 0.04027 | Loss: 0.207 | Acc: 100.000% (1616/1616)
Step: 200 | Loss1: 0.059 | Loss2: 0.05428 | Loss3: 0.05340 | Loss_concat: 0.04029 | Loss: 0.207 | Acc: 100.000% (3216/3216)
Step: 300 | Loss1: 0.058 | Loss2: 0.05420 | Loss3: 0.05406 | Loss_concat: 0.04013 | Loss: 0.207 | Acc: 100.000% (4816/4816)
Step: 1931 | Loss: 0.709 | Acc: 87.780% (5086/5794) |Combined Acc: 87.936% (5095/5794)
best acc is = 88.17742