What is the FOPEN_MAX of the real PSP console? about pspsdk HOT 7 CLOSED

I was interested in this, too. Here's what I found.

First, it's worth mentioning that PSPSDK's libc has a #define _NFILE 16 which limits the number of fopen() handles, if you use that library.

I wrote a test application which tried to open as many different files as possible via sceIoOpen in read-only mode, until the call would fail, and tested it via PSPLINK (too lazy to test it as an EBOOT.PBP).

The application was able to open 56 different files simultaneously. What I think is most interesting is that the highest file descriptor value it could get was 63 (if we include 0, that makes 64 file descriptors, which makes sense to me since it's a power of two).
The smallest file descriptor value (the first) the application could get was 7. Probably the first 3 are stdin, stdout and sterr, and either the 5 others are reserved by the kernel, or used by PSPLINK.

I guess it's reasonable to assume that the kernel reserves 8 file descriptors, and supports up to 64 (per-module? system-wide? idk). These are nice power of two integers.

(edit) I'm testing on a PSP SLIM 2000, with firmware version 6.35.

from pspsdk.

Thanks so much for your reply!
Since the application was able to open 56 different files simultaneously, why PSPSDK's libc has a #define _NFILE 16 ? Is it something like early PSP hardware / software limitation? How could PPSSPP ignore the limitation of _NFILE 16? Is it a hack?

from pspsdk.

why PSPSDK's libc has a #define _NFILE 16 ?

idk, hopefully an expert out there knows, but my I guess is, it could have been a copy-paste or just an educated guess.

How could PPSSPP ignore the limitation of _NFILE 16 ?

Regardless of PPSSPP, the "real" existing PSP games do not use the PSPSDK's libc (which is unofficial), hence I'm pretty sure the limitation is not there (or is way bigger). Not even all homebrew PSP games are guaranteed to use it, because there are various alternatives (e.g newlib).

When building a homebrew PSP game with the current SDK, you can set USE_PSPSDK_LIBC=1 when calling make if you want to use PSPSDK's libc. The alternatives are USE_KERNEL_LIBC=1, or newlib (see src/base/build_prx.mak).

Knowing that, PPSSPP is basically a PSP kernel running on high-end platforms such as PCs. One could look at the source on GitHub if they're so inclined, but I'm guessing at some point they're just using the host's fopen() or equivalent, which has practically no limitation (what's the FOPEN_MAX on PC ? :) ).

from pspsdk.

Thanks so much! That is very important information for me!

Actually I am maintaining the PSP version of a homebrew classic RPG cross-platform reimplementation. I encountered two main problems. One of them is this FOPEN_MAX limiatation. Though I solved it with conditional compilation, but this makes my code unsuitable for being merged into the main stream (The other one is "If bpp is 8, repeated SDL_SetVideoMode calling will cause Display error." pspdev/psplibraries#37 ) .

Thanks again! :)

from pspsdk.

Sorry, I just finished a file demo:
OpenFileTest.zip
It seems only 10 files could be opened simultaneously (fd number 3~12).
Am I doing something wrong? Thanks!

from pspsdk.

In addition, how do we achieve suspend-resume? If a file is being read when suspending, it seems that the pointer position can not be saved? Edit: Solved, but do I have to handle it all by myself? I am not sure whether my solution is stable.

for (int i = 3; i < 13; i++) {
printf("PSP_POWER_CB_SUSPENDING i = %d \n", i);
if (__psp_descriptormap[i]) {
fileseekpoints[i] = ftell(i); // It stops here. Edit: Sorry, I confused fd and fp.
}
}

from pspsdk.

Hello @PalMusicFan,
About 2 years after, I'm coming for closing the issue and giving you more information. About how it is working after the new POSIX toolchain.

I have modified your example:

int main(int argc, char** argv)
{
	SetupCallbacks();
	atexit(sceKernelExitGame);

	pspDebugScreenInit();
	int fd;
	char pathname[30];
	
	for (int i = 1; i <= 69; i++) {
		sprintf(pathname, "%02d.txt", i);
		printf("Opening %s: ", pathname);
		if ((fd = open(pathname, O_RDONLY)) < 0) {
    		printf("Failed\n");
			break;
		}
		printf("OK, fd: %i\n", fd);
		sceKernelDelayThread(100000);
	}

	sceKernelDelayThread(10000000);

	sceKernelExitGame();

    return 0;
}

I have tried in both places PPSSPP and real PSP, in both it behaves exactly the same, and limitation looks to be a PSP OS limitation:

Looks to be that maxium fd files you can open in PSP are 60, having in mind that:

• fd = 0 is for sceKernelStdin
• fd = 1 is for sceKernelStdout
• fd = 2 is for sceKernelStderr
  You can see this info here:
  https://github.com/pspdev/pspsdk/blob/master/src/libcglue/fdman.c#L48-L60
  And for PPSSPP: https://github.com/hrydgard/ppsspp/blob/aefc21f4a36e8add2378f1f3d12c08bf6d78a133/Core/HLE/sceIo.cpp#L122

So fd = 3 would be the first id when an user open a file in his program.

Having in mind that your app needs to open 56 files simultaneously, I think that your problem will be solved with the new toolchain.

Thanks!

from pspsdk.